Archive:Article of the Week: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Russ McGinn
(→‎Current nominees: update score)
m (Text replacement - "CZ:New Draft of the Week" to "Archive:New Draft of the Week")
 
(674 intermediate revisions by 45 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{initiatives}}
__NOTOC__
The Article of the Week is an article chosen by vote among Citizens as exemplifying various qualities we like to see in a ''Citizendium'' article; see our [[CZ:Approval Standards|article standards]]. It is chosen each week by vote in a manner similar to that of its sister project, the [[Archive:New Draft of the Week|New Draft of the Week]]
 
== Add New Nominees Here==
 
'''To add a new nominee or vote for an existing nominee,  click ''edit'' for this section and follow the instructions'''
 
<!--
* Copy the first entry in the table just below to be used as a form to add your nominee.
* Add it to the bottom of the table of nominees.
* Replace the name of the article with the name of the article you are nominating or voting for.
* Delete the supporter and/or specialist supporters names and add your name as either a supporter or specialist fill in your name as either a supporter or a specialist supporter using <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> to add your name, date and time. Any subsequent supporters, separate your name from the other(s) by ''';<br/>'''.
* Delete the score and replace it with your score (1 for a regular supporter, 1 for a specialist supporter of an article created by the specialist and 2 for a specialist supporter of an article not created by the specialist) or add your vote score to the score already there.
 
Add the form you copied to the bottom of the table below. DO NOT delete the |} at the end of the table-->
{| class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto; padding: 6px; background:#fafafa"
|+Table of Nominees
! Nominated article !! Supporters !! Specialist supporters !! Score
|-
| <!-- article              --> {{pl|New nominee name goes here}}
| <!-- supporters            -->
| <!-- specialist supporters -->
| <!-- score                -->
|}


== Transclusion of the above nominees (to be done by an Administrator) ==


== What is the Article of the Week? ==
* Transclude each of the nominees in the above "Table of Nominees" as per the instructions at [[Template:Featured Article Candidate]].
* Then add the transcluded article to the list in the next section below, using the {{tl|Featured Article Candidate}} template.


The Article of the Week is an article chosen by vote among Citizens as exemplifying various qualities we like to see in a ''Citizendium'' article; see our [[CZ:Policy_Outline#Article_Standards|article standards]].
== View Current Transcluded Nominees (after they have been transcluded by an Administrator) ==


== Current nominees ==
The next article (or draft) of the week will be the article with the most votes at 1 AM [[UTC]] on Thursday, 28 October, 2010.
The next article (or draft) of the week will be the article with the most votes at 7 PM UTC on September 25.
{{ptcl-message}}
{| class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto;"
! style="width:50%" | Nominated article
! style="width:22%" | Supporters
! style="width:22%" | Specialist supporters
! Score


{| class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto; padding: 6px; background:#fafafa"
<!--{{Featured Article Candidate
! Nominated article !! Score !! Supporters !! Specialist supporters
| article     = Smog
{{AOTW row
| supporters = [[User:Daniel Mietchen|Daniel Mietchen]] 22:12, 7 September 2010 (UTC)
| article = Edward I
| specialists =
| score = 4
| score      = 1-->
| supporters = [[User:John Stephenson|John Stephenson]] 23:24, 20 September 2007 (CDT); [[User:Carl Jantzen|Carl Jantzen]] 15:26, 21 September 2007 (CDT); &nbsp;&mdash;[[User:Stephen Ewen|Stephen Ewen]]&nbsp;[[User talk:Stephen Ewen|(Talk)]] 03:58, 24 September 2007 (CDT)&nbsp;&mdash;[[User:Russ McGinn|Russ McGinn]] 04:22, 24 September 2007 (CDT)
| specialist supporters =  
}}
}}
{{AOTW row
 
| article = William Shakespeare
| score = 2
| supporters = [[User:Denis Cavanagh|Denis Cavanagh]] 06:31, 24 August 2007 (CDT); --[[User:Matthew Cornell Woods, Jr.|Matthew Cornell Woods, Jr.]] 14:31, 24 August 2007 (CDT)
| specialist supporters =
}}
{{AOTW row
| article = Joan of Arc
| score = 1
| supporters = [[User:Todd Coles|Todd Coles]] 13:42, 4 September 2007 (CDT)
| specialist supporters =
}}
{{AOTW row
| article = Life
| score = 15 (Ineligible until article is re-approved.)
| supporters = [[User:Aleksander Stos|Aleksander Stos]] 08:09, 5 August 2007 (CDT); [[User:Larry Sanger|Larry Sanger]] 22:22, 6 August 2007 (CDT)--[[User:Martin Baldwin-Edwards|Martin Baldwin-Edwards]] 09:24, 7 August 2007 (CDT); &nbsp;&mdash;[[User:Stephen Ewen|Stephen Ewen]]&nbsp;[[User talk:Stephen Ewen|(Talk)]] 10:05, 7 August 2007 (CDT); --[[User:Matthew Cornell Woods, Jr.|Matthew Cornell Woods, Jr.]] 12:38, 8 August 2007 (CDT) [[User:Ruth Ifcher|Ruth Ifcher]] 21:33, 8 August 2007 (CDT)
| specialist supporters = [[User:Chris Day|Chris Day]] [[User talk:Chris Day|(talk)]] 12:43, 8 August 2007 (CDT) (Subject to the article being reapproved.  There are quite a few changes since the last approved version.  <s>Also we need to complete the external links and bibliography as part of that process</s>); [[User:Supten Sarbadhikari|Supten Sarbadhikari]]  --I would like to wait a week or two to follow-up on Chris and Supten's points. --[[User:Anthony.Sebastian|Anthony.Sebastian]] [[User talk:Anthony.Sebastian|(Talk)]] 20:02, 19 August 2007 (CDT)
}}
<!-- INSERT BLANK TEMPLATE HERE TO CREATE NEW NOMINEE.  Place it just above this line -->
|}
|}
<!-- USE THE FOLLOWING AS A BLANK TEMPLATE
 
{{AOTW row
== Current Winner (to be selected and implemented by an Administrator) ==
| article =
 
| score =
''To change, click '''edit''' and follow the instructions, or see documentation at {{tl|Featured Article}}.''
| supporters =
<!--
| specialist supporters =
  Replace article name in {{Featured Article|Article Name}} below. Check for spelling, spaces etc.
}}
  Do not edit anything else - the following line changes the Welcome page automatically.
-->
<!--<onlyinclude>{{Featured Article|Smog}}</onlyinclude>-->
<!--
  Move previous winner articles to the next section
-->
-->


== Previous winning articles ==
== Previous Winners ==
* [[Scotland Yard]] (September 11)
* [[Kilt]] (September 4)
* [[U.S. Electoral College]] (August 28)
* [[Butler]] (August 21)
* [[Tony Blair]] (August 14)
* [[Northwest Passage]] (August 7)
* [[Literature]] (July 31)
* [[Biology]] (July 25)


== Rules and procedure ==
<div style="height:25em; overflow:auto; background:#f9f9f9; border:1px solid #aaa;">
=== Nomination ===
 
* To nominate an article, simply create a new row at the bottom of the [[#Current nominees|current nominees]] list. Use the {{tl|AOTW row}} template. Then alphabetize your nomination, making sure it is not placed above nominees with more votes than your nominee.
{{rpr|Space (mathematics)}}
{{rpr|World of Warcraft}}
{{rpr|Social capital}}
{{rpr|Richard Condon}}
{{rpr|Natural gas}}
{{rpr|Stairway to Heaven}}
{{rpr|Cryptography}}
{{rpr|English spellings}}
{{rpr|Folk saint}}
{{rpr|Led Zeppelin}}
{{rpr|Locality of reference}}
{{rpr|Rabbit}}
{{rpr|Scarborough Castle}} (September 3)
{{rpr|The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order}} (August 27)
{{rpr|Mauna Kea}} (August 20)
{{rpr|Brute force attack}} (August 13)
{{rpr|Cruiser}} (August 5)
{{rpr|The Canterbury Tales}} (July 30)
{{rpr|Milpa agriculture}} (July 23)
{{rpr|Domain Name System}} (July 16)
{{rpr|Scuticaria}} (July 9)
{{rpr|Torture}} (July 2)
{{rpr|Miltonia}} (June 25)
{{rpr|Ancient Celtic music}} (June 18)
{{rpr|Bifrenaria}} (June 11)
{{rpr|Halobacterium NRC-1}} (June 4)
{{rpr|Animal}} (May 28)
{{rpr|Coal}} (May 21)
{{rpr|Johannes Diderik van der Waals}} (May 7)
{{rpr|Scientific method}} (Apr 14)
{{rpr|Korematsu v. United States of America}} (Apr 7)
{{rpr|Orchid}} (Mar 31)
{{rpr|Oliver Cromwell}} (Mar 24)
{{rpr|Wisconsin v. Yoder}} (Mar 17)
{{rpr|Conventional coal-fired power plant}} (Mar 10)
{{rpr|Battle of the Ia Drang}} (Mar 3)
{{rpr|Ether (physics)}} (Feb 24)
{{rpr|Large-scale trickle filters}} (11 Feb)
{{rpr|Homeopathy}} (28 Jan)
{{rpr|Microeconomics}} (14 Jan)
{{rpr|Speech Recognition}} (26 Nov)
{{rpr|Mashup}} (19 Nov)
{{rpr|Tux}} (14 Oct)
{{rpr|Hydrogen bond}} (7 Oct)
{{rpr|Lead}} (1 Sept)
{{rpr|DNA}} (8 July)
{{rpr|Augustin-Louis_Cauchy}} (1 July)
{{rpr|Vasco da Gama}} (24 June)
{{rpr|Phosphorus}} (17 June)
{{rpr|Crystal Palace}} (10 June)
{{rpr|Gross Domestic Product}} (3 June)
{{rpr|RNA interference}} (27 May)
{{rpr|Latino history}} (20 May)
{{rpr|Navy Grog}} (13 May)
{{rpr|Systems biology}} (6 May)
{{rpr|Steroid}} (22 Apr)
{{rpr|Lebanon}} (15 Apr)
{{rpr|Wheat}} (7 Apr)
{{rpr|Benjamin Franklin}} (1 Apr)
{{rpr|Coherer}} (25 Mar)
{{rpr|American Civil War|U.S. Civil War}} (18 Mar)
{{rpr|Life}} (11 Mar)
{{rpr|Petroleum refining processes}} (4 Mar)
{{rpr|Shirley Chisholm}} (20 Feb)
{{rpr|Telephone newspaper|Telephone Newspaper}} (4 Feb)
{{rpr|Wristwatch}} (28 Jan)
{{rpr|Korean War of 1592-1598}} (21 Jan)
{{rpr|Andrew Carnegie}} (11 January 2008)
{{rpr|Bowling}} (31 December 2007)
{{rpr|Architecture}} (December 6)
{{rpr|Civil society}} November 29
{{rpr|Joan of Arc}} (November 22)
{{rpr|Chemistry}} (November 15)
{{rpr|Albert Gallatin}} (November 8)
{{rpr|Prime number}} (November 1)
{{rpr|Tennis}} (October 25)
{{rpr|Rottweiler}} (October 18)
{{rpr|Theodor Lohmann}} (October 9)
{{rpr|William Shakespeare}} (October 2)
{{rpr|Edward I}} (September 25)
{{rpr|El Tío}} (September 18)
{{rpr|Scotland Yard}} (September 11)
{{rpr|Kilt}} (September 4)
{{rpr|U.S. Electoral College}} (August 28)
{{rpr|Butler}} (August 21)
{{rpr|Tony Blair}} (August 14)
{{rpr|Northwest Passage}} (August 7)
{{rpr|Literature}} (July 31)
{{rpr|Biology}} (July 25)
</div>
 
== Rules and Procedure ==
=== Rules ===
* The article's status must be 0 or 1, i.e., only "Advanced Articles" may be nominated.
* The article's status must be 0 or 1, i.e., only "Advanced Articles" may be nominated.
* Any Citizen may nominate an article.
* Any Citizen may nominate an article.
Line 66: Line 164:
* An article can be Article of the Week only once every six months.  Nominated articles that have won top honors should be removed from the list.
* An article can be Article of the Week only once every six months.  Nominated articles that have won top honors should be removed from the list.
* Comments on nominations should be made on the article's talk page.
* Comments on nominations should be made on the article's talk page.
* The list of nominees should be kept below 20, or thereabouts. Articles with very few supporters and which have not gained any new supporters in the last two weeks or so may be deleted to make room for new nominees.
* Any ''editor'' may entirely cancel the nomination of any ''unapproved'' article in his or her area of expertise if, for example, it contains obvious and embarrassing problems.


=== Voting ===
=== Voting ===
* To vote, simply add your name and date next to an article title, after other nominations in the "Supporters" area, by signing <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> (''four'' tildes). (The date is necessary so that we can determine when the last vote was added.)
* To vote, add your name and date in the ''Supporters'' column next to an article title, after other supporters for that article, by signing <code><nowiki><br />~~~~</nowiki></code>. (The date is necessary so that we can determine when the last vote was added.) Your vote is alloted a score of 1.
* You may vote for as many articles as you wish, and each vote counts separately, but you can only nominate one at a time; see above.  You could, theoretically, vote for every nominated article on the page.
* Add your name in the ''Specialist supporters'' column only if you are an editor who is an expert about the topic in question. Your vote is alloted a score of 1 for articles which you created and a score of 2 for articles which you did not create.
* Add your name in the "Specialist supporters" column only if you are an editor who is an expert about the topic in question.  Your vote will be counted as three.
* You may vote for as many articles as you wish, and each vote counts separately, but you can only ''nominate'' one at a time; see above.  You could, theoretically, vote for every nominated article on the page, but this would be pointless.


=== Ranking ===
=== Ranking ===
* Nominations are listed by number of votes first, then alphabetically.
* The list of articles is sorted by number of votes first, then alphabetically.
* Admins should make sure the votes are correctly tallied, but anyone may do this.  Note that "Specialist Votes" are worth three.
* Admins should make sure that the votes are correctly tallied, but anyone may do this.  Note that "Specialist Votes" are worth 3 points.


=== Deleting ===
=== Updating ===
* If the list of nominees should be kept to 20 (or some similar reasonable number).  Nominees that have very few supporters and which have not garnered any new supporters in the last, say, two weeks may be deleted to make room for new nominees.  (We'll have to solidify this rule.)
* Each Thursday, one of the admins listed below should move the winning article to the [[#Current Winner|Current Winner]] section of this page, announces the winner on Citizendium-L and updates the "previous winning articles" section accordingly.
* Any editor may, simply by editing the nomination list (or [[CZ talk:Article of the Week|the talk page]]), entirely cancel the nomination of any ''unapproved'' article in his or her area of expertise (if, for example, it contains obvious and embarrassing problems).
* The winning article will be the article at the top of the list (''ie'' the one with the most votes).
 
* In the event of two or more having the same number of votes :
=== Choosing the weekly winner ===
** The article with the ''most specialist supporters'' is used. Should this fail to produce a winner, the article appearing ''first by English alphabetical order'' is used.<br />
* Each Tuesday (at 7 PM UTC; 2 PM EST; 11 AM PST; 4 AM Sydney), one of the program admins--the first one who has the honor--moves the article that is at the top of the list (i.e., the one with the most votes) to the front page, announces the winner on Citizendium-L and updates the "previous winning articles" section accordingly.
** The remaining winning articles are guaranteed this position in the following weeks, again in alphabetical order. No further voting would take place on these, which remain at the top of the table with notices to that effect. Further nominations and voting take place to determine future winning articles for the following weeks.
* If you are volunteering to change the article of the week on the front page, then say so above the "article nominees" table ("I'm doing the honors this time" -- Jane Doe) so that no one else does it.
* If an article has not been approved yet, the article of the week is re-labelled "Draft of the Week."  Be sure to pay attention to this!
* When updating the main page, be sure to change the [more...] link at the bottom to match the new article as well.
 
====In the event of a tie====
''Where two or more articles have achieved an equal number of votes, the following procedure shall be used to break the deadlock:''
* '''Number of specialist supporters''': the article with most specialist supporters goes through.
 
''Should this fail to produce a winner'':
 
* '''Alphabetical order''': The article appearing first by English alphabetical order shall be named Article of the Week.  
* The remaining winning articles are guaranteed this position in the following weeks, again in alphabetical order. No further voting would take place on these, which remain at the top of the table with notices to that effect.
* Further nominations and voting take place to determine future winning articles for the following weeks.


== Administrators ==
== Administrators ==


These are people who have volunteered to run this program.  Their duties are (1) to ensure that this page remains "clean," e.g., as a given article garners more votes, its tally is accurately represented and it moves up the list, and (2) to place the winning article on the front page each Tuesday at 7 PM UTC (2 PM EST; 11 AM PST; 4 AM Sydney, sorry).
These are people who have volunteered to run this program.  Their duties are (1) to ensure that this page remains "clean," e.g., as a given article garners more votes, its tally is accurately represented and it moves up the list, and (2) to place the winning article on the front page on a weekly basis.
 
To become an administrator, you need not apply anywhere.  Simply add your name below.  Administrator duties are open to editors and authors alike.
To become an administrator, you need not apply anywhere.  Simply add your name below.  Administrator duties are open to editors and authors alike.


* [[User:Carl_Jantzen|Carl Jantzen]]
* [[User:Carl_Jantzen|Carl Jantzen]]
* [[User:Todd Coles|Todd Coles]]
* [[User:Todd Coles|Todd Coles]]
* ''picture your name here!'' :-)
* [[User:David E. Volk|David E. Volk]]
* [[User:Milton Beychok|Milton Beychok]]
 
==References==
<!--The content of this section may change automatically as articles are added to or removed from the list, or as listed articles are being edited.-->
{{reflist}}


== Other periodical community content initiatives ==
== See Also ==
* [[CZ:New Draft of the Week]]
* [[Archive:New Draft of the Week]]
* [[CZ:Markup tags for partial transclusion of selected text in an article]]
* [[CZ:Monthly Write-a-Thon]]
* [[CZ:Monthly Write-a-Thon]]
* [[CZ:Weekly Wiki]]
 
{{initiatives}}
[[Category:Archived Pages]]

Latest revision as of 04:06, 8 March 2024

The Article of the Week is an article chosen by vote among Citizens as exemplifying various qualities we like to see in a Citizendium article; see our article standards. It is chosen each week by vote in a manner similar to that of its sister project, the New Draft of the Week

Add New Nominees Here

To add a new nominee or vote for an existing nominee, click edit for this section and follow the instructions

Table of Nominees
Nominated article Supporters Specialist supporters Score
New nominee name goes here

Transclusion of the above nominees (to be done by an Administrator)

View Current Transcluded Nominees (after they have been transcluded by an Administrator)

The next article (or draft) of the week will be the article with the most votes at 1 AM UTC on Thursday, 28 October, 2010.

Text in this section is transcluded from the respective Citizendium entries and may change when these are edited.

Nominated article Supporters Specialist supporters Score

}}

Current Winner (to be selected and implemented by an Administrator)

To change, click edit and follow the instructions, or see documentation at {{Featured Article}}.

Previous Winners

Rules and Procedure

Rules

  • The article's status must be 0 or 1, i.e., only "Advanced Articles" may be nominated.
  • Any Citizen may nominate an article.
  • No Citizen may have nominated more than one article listed under "current nominees" at a time.
  • The article's nominator is indicated simply by the first name in the list of votes (see below).
  • At least for now--while the project is still small--you may nominate and vote for articles of which you are a main author.
  • An article can be Article of the Week only once every six months. Nominated articles that have won top honors should be removed from the list.
  • Comments on nominations should be made on the article's talk page.
  • The list of nominees should be kept below 20, or thereabouts. Articles with very few supporters and which have not gained any new supporters in the last two weeks or so may be deleted to make room for new nominees.
  • Any editor may entirely cancel the nomination of any unapproved article in his or her area of expertise if, for example, it contains obvious and embarrassing problems.

Voting

  • To vote, add your name and date in the Supporters column next to an article title, after other supporters for that article, by signing <br />~~~~. (The date is necessary so that we can determine when the last vote was added.) Your vote is alloted a score of 1.
  • Add your name in the Specialist supporters column only if you are an editor who is an expert about the topic in question. Your vote is alloted a score of 1 for articles which you created and a score of 2 for articles which you did not create.
  • You may vote for as many articles as you wish, and each vote counts separately, but you can only nominate one at a time; see above. You could, theoretically, vote for every nominated article on the page, but this would be pointless.

Ranking

  • The list of articles is sorted by number of votes first, then alphabetically.
  • Admins should make sure that the votes are correctly tallied, but anyone may do this. Note that "Specialist Votes" are worth 3 points.

Updating

  • Each Thursday, one of the admins listed below should move the winning article to the Current Winner section of this page, announces the winner on Citizendium-L and updates the "previous winning articles" section accordingly.
  • The winning article will be the article at the top of the list (ie the one with the most votes).
  • In the event of two or more having the same number of votes :
    • The article with the most specialist supporters is used. Should this fail to produce a winner, the article appearing first by English alphabetical order is used.
    • The remaining winning articles are guaranteed this position in the following weeks, again in alphabetical order. No further voting would take place on these, which remain at the top of the table with notices to that effect. Further nominations and voting take place to determine future winning articles for the following weeks.

Administrators

These are people who have volunteered to run this program. Their duties are (1) to ensure that this page remains "clean," e.g., as a given article garners more votes, its tally is accurately represented and it moves up the list, and (2) to place the winning article on the front page on a weekly basis. To become an administrator, you need not apply anywhere. Simply add your name below. Administrator duties are open to editors and authors alike.

References

See Also


Citizendium Initiatives
Eduzendium | Featured Article | Recruitment | Subpages | Core Articles | Uncategorized pages |
Requested Articles | Feedback Requests | Wanted Articles

|width=10% align=center style="background:#F5F5F5"|  |}

Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=Archive:Article_of_the_Week&oldid=928937"