User talk:Thomas Wright Sulcer/sandbox11: Difference between revisions
imported>Thomas Wright Sulcer (added more info; put Google's PageRank data from tool used directly) |
imported>Thomas Wright Sulcer (tweaking data) |
||
Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Business]] <!--Article---> ||200707 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Ian Johnson <!--CZ creator---> ||3<!--Article Google rank---> ||0/10<!--Google's PageRank--->||9999 <!--Category rank---> ||18 <!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||3<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || "CZ:Business Workgroup" was 2nd; the business article was 3rd - <!--Notes---> | |[[Business]] <!--Article---> ||200707 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Ian Johnson <!--CZ creator---> ||3<!--Article Google rank---> ||0/10<!--Google's PageRank--->||9999 <!--Category rank---> ||18 <!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||3<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || "CZ:Business Workgroup" was 2nd; the business article was 3rd - <!--Notes---> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Truth]] <!--Article---> ||200805 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Larry Sanger <!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||2/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| 9999<!--Category rank---> ||11 <!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||5<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> ||Jacques Derrida, and Aesthetics came up #2 and #3 <!--Notes---> | |[[Truth]] <!--Article---> ||200805 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Larry Sanger <!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||2/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| 9999<!--Category rank---> ||11 <!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||5<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> ||Jacques Derrida, and Aesthetics came up #2 and #3 <!--Notes---> | ||
Line 82: | Line 80: | ||
|[[Chimpanzee]] <!--Article---> ||200802 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Wilson Rondini IV <!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||3/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||35<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||7<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | |[[Chimpanzee]] <!--Article---> ||200802 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Wilson Rondini IV <!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||3/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||35<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||7<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Money]] <!--Article---> || <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Anthony Argyriou <!--CZ creator---> || | |[[Money]] <!--Article---> ||200706 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Anthony Argyriou <!--CZ creator---> ||3<!--Article Google rank---> ||3/10<!--Google's PageRank--->||9999 <!--Category rank---> ||12 <!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||5<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> ||"Money supply" on CZ came up first, "Monetarism" came up 2nd <!--Notes---> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Money supply]]<!--Article [[]]---> || <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Nick Gardner<!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||3/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||11<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||2<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | |[[Money supply]]<!--Article [[]]---> ||200811 <!--YYYYDD created---> ||Nick Gardner<!--CZ creator---> ||1<!--Article Google rank---> ||3/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||11<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||2<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | ||
|- | |- | ||
| <!--Article [[]]---> || <!--YYYYDD created---> ||<!--CZ creator---> ||<!--Article Google rank---> ||0/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | | <!--Article [[]]---> || <!--YYYYDD created---> ||<!--CZ creator---> ||<!--Article Google rank---> ||0/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> | ||
Line 95: | Line 93: | ||
Note: CZ contributors INCLUDES bots (since a Google crawler probably can't tell the difference between a person and a bot) | Note: CZ contributors INCLUDES bots (since a Google crawler probably can't tell the difference between a person and a bot) | ||
Shell for adding more: | |||
<!--- |[[]] <!--Article ---> || <!--YYYYDD created---> ||<!--CZ creator---> ||<!--Article Google rank---> ||0/10<!--Google's PageRank--->|| <!--Category rank---> ||<!--Number of CZ revisions---> ||d<!--Approved or Draft?---> ||<!--# CZ contributors (est)---> || <!--Notes---> ---> |
Revision as of 20:34, 19 March 2010
Why do CZ articles sometimes fail to appear in Google searches? I looked at various CZ articles, created at different times by different people, looked at different variables such as # revisions, # contributors, creation date (sortable format, so later dates are numerically higher). For each, I typed this into a google searchbar, putting the exact article name in quotes: "Exact article name" citizendium
What rank did each one get? The rank is the entry number; so if it appeared on the first page in the fourth slot, it got a rank of "4"; I counted subgroups too. If it didn't appear after a page or two of searching, I put 9999 meaning I didn't find it. My working hypothesis is: CZ's Related Article subpages CONFUSE Google's crawlers. They have trouble figuring what links to what. As a result, CZ's internal links are TOO COMPLEX and CZ's web presence is harmed as a result. Date is a big variable; organize it by date first, then article google rank second; there are no articles created in 2009 that achieved a #1 spot EVEN WITH THE WORD "CITIZENDIUM" in the search bar.
CZ article title | Date created (eg 200707 = July 2007) | CZ creator | Article's Google rank (1=BEST) (9999=doesn't appear) | Google PageRank 10/10=BEST 0/10=totally obscure | Category Google rank | Number of CZ revisions | approved (a) or draft (d) | # CZ contributors (people) (est) | Notes |
Terrorism | 200712 | D. Matt Innis | 1 | 3/10 | 9999 | 8 | a | 3 | |
Lucille Ball | 200812 | Paul Wormer | 4 | 0/10 | 3 | 4 | d | 3 | |
Script kiddie | 201002 | Thomas Wright Sulcer | 0/10 | 9999 | d | ||||
Dana Delany | 201002 | Thomas Wright Sulcer | 9999 | 0/10 | 1 | 2 | d | ||
Lady Gaga | 201002 | Thomas Wright Sulcer | 9999 | 0/10 | 9999 | 13 | d | 4 | |
Bromance | 201003 | Thomas Wright Sulcer | 9999 | 0/10 | 9999 | 6 | d | 1 | |
Albert Einstein | 200611 | Nancy Sculerati MD | 1 | 3/10 | 9999 | 42 | d | 17 | |
Restructuring of the United States Army | 200807 | Howard C. Berkowitz | 1 | 2/10 | 54 | d | 5 | ||
Solid harmonics | 200708 | Paul Wormer | 1 | 0/10 | 21 | 22 | d | 3 | |
Plane (geometry) | 200703 | John Roby Clayton | 1 | 0/10 | 16 | d | 9 | ||
Gaussian elimination | 200905 | David E. Volk | 9999 | 0/10 | 1 | 8 | d | 2 | Note: this is what appeared first on google: "CZ:Core Articles > Mathematics" not the CZ article; this came third: "Talk:Gaussian elimination" |
Linear algebra | 200811 | Barry R. Smith | 1 | 2/10 | 9999 | 2 | d | 1 | |
Cloud computing | 200807 | Ashwath Ravichandran | 4 | 2/10 | 9999 | 117 | d | 6 | CZ really first; three ads for CC came up first |
Horticulture | 200612 | Nancy Sculerati MD | 1 | 2/10 | 9999 | 13 | d | 7 | "CZ: workgroup requests" ranks 2nd |
Business | 200707 | Ian Johnson | 3 | 0/10 | 9999 | 18 | d | 3 | "CZ:Business Workgroup" was 2nd; the business article was 3rd - |
Truth | 200805 | Larry Sanger | 1 | 2/10 | 9999 | 11 | d | 5 | Jacques Derrida, and Aesthetics came up #2 and #3 |
Anthropology | 200707 | Chris Day | 1 | 4/10 | 9999 | 41 | d | 10 | CZ:anthropology workgroup came up #9 |
Applied social sciences | 200803 | Roger Lohmann | 1 | 2/10 | 9999 | 15 | d | 6 | Anthro:catalogs 3/10 biblio 3/10 rel art 3/10 |
Henry Ford | 200704 | Richard Jensen | 1 | 3/10 | 41 | d | 10 | HF's external links, and bibliography were #2 and #3 | |
Nobel Prize | 200810 | Daniel Mietchen | 1 | 3/10 | 9999 | 9 | d | 4 | |
Norway | 200705 | Kjetil Ree | 2 | 0/10 | 56 | d | 4 | The Norway "Gallery" came up 1st; a collection of images about Norway. | |
Great Britain | 200704 | Richard Jensen | 1 | 3/10 | 9999 | 39 | d | 6 | |
United Kingdom | 200611 | Rilson Versuri | 2 | 0/10 | 9999 | 163 | d | 22 | What came first? "Parliament of the United Kingdom - encyclopedia article - Citizendium" Why? "Catalogs" came 3rd. |
Scottish Parliament | 200801 | Gareth Leng | 1 | 2/10 | 12 | d | 4 | ||
Royal Palace of Holyroodhouse | 200805 | Gareth Leng | 6 | 0/10 | 12 | 7 | d | 2 | First: Royal Mile article on CZ; second: Edinburgh (external links); third: Scottish Parliament; 4th = RP of H (related articles) |
Arthur's Seat | 200801 | Gareth Leng | 1 | 0/10 | 6 | d | 4 | Scottish Parliament article #2; Royal Mile article #3; Arthur's Seat external links comes #7 | |
Photosynthesis | 200808 | Anthony.Sebastian | 1 | 2/10 | 108 | d | 6 | Photosynthesis "Gallery" comes #2 | |
Handyman | 201002 | Thomas Wright Sulcer | 9999 | 0/10 | 24 | d | 2 | CZ's Cottage industry comes 1st; Tool related articles comes #5 | |
Guitar | 200810 | Kiryl Rusetski | 1 | 0/10 | 9999 | 10 | d | 7 | |
Hierarchical clustering | 200911 | Daniel Mietchen | 3 | 0/10 | 7 | d | 2 | CZ article "Bioinformatics - encyclopedia article - Citizendium" comes 1st; the talk page of Hc comes about 8th. | |
Human | 200710 | Philippe Tusler | 1 | 4/10 | 9 | d | 6 | ||
Chimpanzee | 200802 | Wilson Rondini IV | 1 | 3/10 | 35 | d | 7 | ||
Money | 200706 | Anthony Argyriou | 3 | 3/10 | 9999 | 12 | d | 5 | "Money supply" on CZ came up first, "Monetarism" came up 2nd |
Money supply | 200811 | Nick Gardner | 1 | 3/10 | 11 | d | 2 | ||
0/10 | d |
Notes
NOte: after the first 5 or 10 pages of a google search, I stopped looking, and would put down "rank" as 9999, meaning "I didn't find it"
Note: CZ contributors INCLUDES bots (since a Google crawler probably can't tell the difference between a person and a bot)
Shell for adding more:
|| || || ||0/10|| || ||d || || --->