Molecular Hamiltonian

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This article is developed but not approved.
Main Article
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
This editable, developed Main Article is subject to a disclaimer.

In atomic, molecular, and optical physics, as well as in quantum chemistry, molecular Hamiltonian is the name given to the operator that represents the energy of the electrons and nuclei in a molecule. This Hermitian operator plays a central role in computational chemistry and physics. Many properties of molecules and aggregates of molecules can be obtained by numerical determination of the eigenvalues of the molecular Hamiltonian, (i.e., by solution of the associated time-independent Schrödinger equation). Properties that can be computed are first and foremost (reaction) energies, but also optical properties, such as the index of refraction, and magnetic properties, such as magnetic susceptibility, may be obtained from calculation.


The bricks of a molecule are its nuclei and the electrons are its mortar. Electrons have negative elementary chargeq and the charge of a nucleus, characterized uniquely by its atomic number Z, is Zq. Electrons and nuclei are, to a very good approximation, point charges and point masses, that is, their mechanical dimensions are so minute that they can be neglected. The molecular Hamiltonian is then a sum of several energy terms. The major ones are the Coulomb (electrostatic) interactions between its point charges (electron-electron, electron-nucleus, and nucleus-nucleus interactions) and the kinetic energies of its point masses, the electrons and nuclei. The Hamiltonian that contains only these major terms is known as the Coulomb Hamiltonian. From it are missing a number of small terms, most of which are due to electronic and nuclear spin. Usually these missing terms are collectively referred to as magnetic and relativistic effects.

Although it is generally assumed that the solution of the time-independent Schrödinger equation associated with the Coulomb Hamiltonian will predict most properties of the molecule, including its shape (three-dimensional structure), calculations based on the full Coulomb Hamiltonian are very rare. The main reason is that its Schrödinger equation is almost impossible to solve, even approximately. Applications based on the full Coulomb Hamiltonian are restricted to small systems like the hydrogen molecule.

Almost all calculations of molecular wave functions depart from the separation of the Coulomb Hamiltonian, first devised by Born and Oppenheimer, into an electronic and a nuclear part. The nuclear kinetic energy terms—that contribute much less to the energy than the kinetic energies of the electrons—are omitted from the Coulomb Hamiltonian and one considers the remaining Hamiltonian as a Hamiltonian of electrons only. The stationary nuclei enter the problem only as creators of an electric field in which the electrons move in a quantum mechanical way. Within this framework the molecular Hamiltonian has been simplified to the so-called clamped nucleus Hamiltonian, also called electronic Hamiltonian, that acts only on functions of the electronic coordinates.

Once the eigenvalue equation (time-independent Schrödinger equation) of the clamped nucleus Hamiltonian has been solved for a sufficient number of constellations of the nuclei, the set of eigenvalues (usually the lowest) can be seen as a function of the nuclear coordinates, a function in multi-dimensional space, the potential energy surface (PES) of the molecule. For most common molecules (the so-called semi-rigid molecules), this surface has one or more deep minima separated by high potential barriers. These minima correspond to different stable conformations of the molecule. In the clamped nucleus approximation, the nuclei are immovable and the moving electrons glue the nuclei together, whence the brick and mortar metaphor.

In practical calculations the PES is usually fitted in terms of some analytic functions. In the second step of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation the part of the full Coulomb Hamiltonian that depends on the electrons is replaced by the PES. This converts the total molecular Hamiltonian into another Hamiltonian that acts only on the nuclear coordinates. This Hamiltonian describes the quantum mechanical motion (translation, rotation, and vibration) of the nuclei. In the case of a breakdown of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation—which occurs when energies of different electronic states are close—the neighboring potential energy surfaces are needed, see the article on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation for more details.

The nuclear motion Schrödinger equation can be solved in a space-fixed (laboratory) frame, but then the translational and rotational (external) energies are not accounted for. The equilibrium nuclear skeleton is then fixed in space. Only the (internal) nuclear vibrations around the equilibrium enter the problem. Further, for molecules larger than triatomic ones, it is quite common to introduce the harmonic approximation, which approximates the potential energy surface as a quadratic function of the atomic displacements. This gives the harmonic nuclear motion Hamiltonian. Making the harmonic approximation, we can convert the Hamiltonian into a sum of uncoupled one-dimensional harmonic oscillator Hamiltonians. The harmonic oscillator is one of the few systems that allows an exact solution of the Schrödinger equation.

Alternatively, the nuclear motion (rovibrational) Schrödinger equation can be solved in a special frame (an Eckart frame) that rotates and translates with the molecule. Formulated with respect to this body-fixed frame the Hamiltonian accounts for rotation, translation and vibration of the nuclei. Since Watson introduced in 1968 an important simplification to this Hamiltonian, it is often referred to as Watson's nuclear motion Hamiltonian, but it is also known as the Eckart Hamiltonian, after Carl Eckart, who introduced its initial form in 1935.

Coulomb Hamiltonian

The algebraic form of many observables—i.e., Hermitian operators representing observable quantities—is obtained by the following quantization rules:

  • Write the classical form of the observable in Hamilton form (as a function of momenta p and positions q). Both vectors are expressed with respect to an arbitrary inertial frame, usually referred to as laboratory-frame or space-fixed frame.
  • Replace p by and interpret q as a multiplicative operator. Here is the nabla operator, a vector operator consisting of first derivatives. The well-known commutation relations for the p and q operators follow directly from the differentiation rules.

Classically the electrons and nuclei in a molecule have kinetic energy of the form p2/(2m) and interact via Coulomb interactions, which are inversely proportional to the distance rij between particle i and j.

In this expression ri stands for the coordinate vector of any particle (electron or nucleus). But from here on we will reserve capital R to represent the nuclear coordinate, and lower case r for the electrons of the system. The coordinates can be taken to be expressed with respect to any Cartesian frame centered anywhere in space, because distance, being an inner product, is invariant under rotation of the frame and, being the norm of a difference vector, distance is invariant under translation of the frame as well.

By quantizing the classical energy in Hamilton form one obtains the a molecular Hamilton operator that is often referred to as the Coulomb Hamiltonian. This Hamiltonian is a sum of 5 terms. They are

  1. The kinetic energy operators for each nucleus in the system;
  2. The kinetic energy operators for each electron in the system;
  3. The potential energy between the electrons and nuclei - the total electron-nucleus Coulombic attraction in the system;
  4. The potential energy arising from Coulombic electron-electron repulsions
  5. The potential energy arising from Coulombic nuclei-nuclei repulsions - also known as the nuclear repulsion energy. See electric potential for more details.

Here Mi is the mass of nucleus i, Zi is the atomic number of nucleus i, and me is the mass of the electron. The Laplace operator of particle i is :. Since the kinetic energy operator is an inner product, it is invariant under rotation of the Cartesian frame with respect to which xi, yi, and zi are expressed. The kinetic energy operator, however, is not invariant under translation (choice of origin of the frame).

Small terms

In the 1920s, much spectroscopic evidence made it clear that the Coulomb Hamiltonian is missing certain terms. Especially for molecules containing heavier atoms, these terms, although much smaller than kinetic and Coulomb energies, are non-negligible. These spectroscopic observations led to the introduction of a new degree of freedom for electrons and nuclei, namely spin. The empirical concept of spin was given a theoretical basis by Dirac when he introduced a relativistically correct (Lorentz covariant) form of the one-particle Schrödinger equation. The Dirac equation predicts that spin and spatial (orbital) motion of a particle interact via spin-orbit coupling. In analogy spin-other-orbit coupling was introduced. The fact that particle spin has some of the characteristics of a magnetic dipole led to spin-spin coupling. Other terms without a classical counterpart are the Fermi-contact term (interaction of electronic density on a finite size nucleus with the nucleus), and nuclear quadrupole coupling (interaction of a nuclear quadrupole with the gradient of an electric field due to the electrons). Finally a parity violating term predicted by the Standard Model must be mentioned. Although it is an extremely small interaction, it has attracted a fair amount of attention in the scientific literature because it gives different energies for the enantiomers in chiral molecules.

The remaining part of this article will ignore spin and other relativistic terms and considers the solution of the eigenvalue (time-independent Schrödinger) equation of the Coulomb Hamiltonian.

The Schrödinger equation of the Coulomb Hamiltonian

The Coulomb Hamiltonian has a continuous spectrum due to the center of mass motion of the molecule in homogeneous space. In classical mechanics it is easy to separate off the center of mass (COM) motion of a system of point masses. Classically the motion of the COM is uncoupled from the other motions. The COM moves uniformly (i.e., with constant velocity) through space as if it were a point particle with mass equal to the sum Mtot of the masses of all the particles.

In quantum mechanics a free particle has as state function a plane wave function, which is a non-square-integrable function of well-defined momentum. The kinetic energy of this particle covers , i.e., is real, continuous, and positive. The position of the COM is uniformly probable everywhere, in agreement with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

Quantum mechanically the proper separation of the COM motion is much more cumbersome than in classical mechanics. By introducing the coordinate vector of the center of mass as three of the degrees of freedom of the system and eliminating the coordinate vector of one (arbitrary) particle, so that the number of degrees of freedom stays the same, one obtains by a linear transformation a new set of coordinates ti. These coordinates are linear combinations of the old coordinates of all particles (nuclei and electrons). By applying the chain rule one can show that

The first term of H is the kinetic energy of the COM motion, which can be treated separately since H' does not depend on . As just stated, its eigenstates are plane waves. The constants 1/μij are positive and are linear combinations of all the inverse masses 1/mi. They are generalized reduced masses. The potential consists of the Coulomb terms expressed in the new coordinates. The first term of H' has the usual appearance of a kinetic energy operator. The second term is known as the mass polarization term. The translationally invariant Hamiltonian H' can be shown to be self-adjoint and to be bounded from below. That is, its lowest eigenvalue is real and finite. Although H' is necessarily invariant under permutations of identical particles (since H and the COM kinetic energy are invariant), its invariance is not manifest.

Not many actual molecular applications of H' exist, see, however, the seminal work[1] on the hydrogen molecule for an early application. In the great majority of computations of molecular wave functions the electronic problem is solved with the clamped nucleus Hamiltonian arising in the first step of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation.

See Ref.[2] for a thorough discussion of the mathematical properties of the Coulomb Hamiltonian. Also it is discussed in this paper whether one can arrive a priori at the concept of a molecule (as a stable system of electrons and nuclei with a well-defined geometry) from the properties of the Coulomb Hamiltonian alone.

Clamped nucleus (electronic) Hamiltonian

The clamped nucleus Hamiltonian (also known as the electronic Hamiltonian) describes the energy of the electrons in the electrostatic field of the nuclei, where the nuclei are assumed to be stationary with respect to an inertial frame. The form of the electronic Hamiltonian is

The coordinates of electrons and nuclei are expressed with respect to a frame that moves with the nuclei, so that the nuclei are at rest with respect to this frame. The frame stays parallel to a space-fixed frame. It is an inertial frame because the nuclei are assumed not to be accelerated by external forces or torques. The origin of the frame is arbitrary, it is usually positioned on a central nucleus or in the nuclear center of mass. Sometimes it is stated that the nuclei are "at rest in a space-fixed frame". This statement implies that the nuclei are viewed as classical particles, because a quantum mechanical particle cannot be at rest. (It would mean that it had simultaneously zero momentum and well-defined position, which contradicts Heisenberg's uncertainty principle).

Since the nuclear positions are constants, the electronic kinetic energy operator is invariant under translation over any nuclear vector. The Coulomb potential, depending on difference vectors, is invariant as well. In the description of atomic orbitals and the computation of integrals over atomic orbitals this invariance is used by equipping all atoms in the molecule with their own localized frames parallel to the space-fixed frame.

As explained in the article on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, a sufficient number of solutions of the Schrödinger equation of leads to a potential energy surface (PES) . It is assumed that the functional dependence of V on its coordinates is such that


where t and s are arbitrary vectors and Δφ is an infinitesimal angle, Δφ >> Δφ2. This invariance condition on the PES is automatically fulfilled when the PES is expressed in terms of differences of, and angles between, the Ri, which is usually the case.

Harmonic nuclear motion Hamiltonian

In the remaining part of this article we assume that the molecule is semi-rigid. In the second step of the BO approximation the nuclear kinetic energy Tn is reintroduced and the Schrödinger equation with Hamiltonian

is considered. One would like to recognize in its solution: the motion of the nuclear center of mass (3 degrees of freedom), the overall rotation of the molecule (3 degrees of freedom), and the nuclear vibrations. In general, this is not possible with the given nuclear kinetic energy, because it does not separate explicitly the 6 external degrees of freedom (overall translation and rotation) from the 3N-6 internal degrees of freedom. In fact, the kinetic energy operator here is defined with respect to a space-fixed (SF) frame. If we were to move the origin of the SF frame to the nuclear center of mass, then, by application of the chain rule, nuclear mass polarization terms would appear. It is customary to ignore these terms altogether and we will follow this custom.

In order to achieve a separation we must distinguish internal and external coordinates, to which end Eckart introduced conditions to be satisfied by the coordinates. We will show how these conditions arise in a natural way from a harmonic analysis in mass-weighted Cartesian coordinates.

In order to simplify the expression for the kinetic energy we introduce mass-weighted displacement coordinates



the kinetic energy operator becomes,

If we make a Taylor expansion of V around the equilibrium geometry,

and truncate after three terms (the so-called harmonic approximation), we can describe V with only the third term. The term V0 can be absorbed in the energy (gives a new zero of energy). The second term is vanishing because of the equilibrium condition. The remaining term contains the Hessian matrix F of V, which is symmetric and may be diagonalized with an orthogonal 3N x 3N matrix with constant elements:

It can be shown from the invariance of V under rotation and translation that six of the eigenvectors of F (last six rows of Q) have eigenvalue zero (are zero-frequency modes). They span the external space. The first 3N-6 rows of Q are—for molecules in their ground state—eigenvectors with non-zero eigenvalue; they are the internal coordinates and form an orthonormal basis for a 3N - 6 dimensional subspace of the nuclear configuration space R3N, the internal space. The zero-frequency eigenvectors are orthogonal to the eigenvectors of non-zero frequency. It can be shown that these orthogonalities are in fact the Eckart conditions. The kinetic energy expressed in the internal coordinates is the internal (vibrational) kinetic energy.

With the introduction of normal coordinates

the vibrational (internal) part of the Hamiltonian for the nuclear motion becomes in the harmonic approximation

The corresponding Schrödinger equation is easily solved, it factorizes into 3N-6 equations for one-dimensional harmonic oscillators. The main effort in this approximate solution of the nuclear motion Schrödinger equation is the computation of the Hessian F of V and its diagonalization.

This approximation to the nuclear motion problem, described in 3N mass-weighted Cartesian coordinates, became standard in quantum chemistry, since the days (1980s-1990s) that algorithms for accurate computations of the Hessian F became available. Apart from the harmonic approximation, it has as a further deficiency that the external (rotational and translational) motions of the molecule are not accounted for. They are accounted for in a rovibrational Hamiltonian that sometimes is called Watson's Hamiltonian.

Watson's nuclear motion Hamiltonian

In order to obtain a Hamiltonian for external (translation and rotation) motions coupled to the internal (vibrational) motions, it is common to return at this point to classical mechanics and to formulate the classical kinetic energy corresponding to these motions of the nuclei. Classically it is easy to separate the translational—center of mass—motion from the other motions. However, the separation of the rotational from the vibrational motion is more difficult and is not completely possible. This ro-vibrational separation was first achieved by Eckart[3] in 1935 by imposing by what is now known as Eckart conditions. Since the problem is described in a frame (an "Eckart" frame) that rotates with the molecule, and hence is a non-inertial frame, energies associated with the fictitious forces: centrifugal and Coriolis force appear in the kinetic energy.

In general, the classical kinetic energy T defines the metric tensor g = (gij) associated with the curvilinear coordinates s = (si) through


The quantization step is the transformation of this classical kinetic energy into a quantum mechanical operator. It is common to follow Podolsky[4] by writing down the Laplace-Beltrami operator in the same (generalized, curvilinear) coordinates s as used for the classical form. The equation for this operator requires the inverse of the metric tensor g and its determinant. Multiplication of the Laplace-Beltrami operator by gives the required quantum mechanical kinetic energy operator. When we apply this recipe to Cartesian coordinates, which have unit metric, the same kinetic energy is obtained as by application of the quantization rules.

The nuclear motion Hamiltonian was obtained by Wilson and Howard in 1936, [5] who followed this procedure, and further refined by Darling and Dennison in 1940.[6] It remained the standard until 1968, when Watson[7] was able to simplify it drastically by commuting through the derivatives the determinant of the metric tensor. We will give the ro-vibrational Hamiltonian obtained by Watson, which often is referred to as the Watson Hamiltonian. Before we do this we must mention that a derivation of this Hamiltonian is also possible by starting from the Laplace operator in Cartesian form, application of coordinate transformations, and use of the chain rule.[8] The Watson Hamiltonian, describing all motions of the N nuclei, is

The first term is the center of mass term

The second term is the rotational term akin to the kinetic energy of the rigid rotor. Here is the α component of the body-fixed rigid rotor angular momentum operator, see this article for its expression in terms of Euler angles. The operator is a component of an operator known as the vibrational angular momentum operator (although it does not satisfy angular momentum commutation relations),

with the Coriolis coupling constant:

Here εαβγ is the Levi-Civita symbol. The terms quadratic in the are centrifugal terms, those bilinear in and are Coriolis terms. The quantities Q s, iγ are the components of the normal coordinates introduced above. Alternatively, normal coordinates may be obtained by application of Wilson's GF method. The 3 x 3 symmetric matrix is called the effective reciprocal inertia tensor. If all q s were zero (rigid molecule) the Eckart frame would coincide with a principal axes frame (see rigid rotor) and would be diagonal, with the equilibrium reciprocal moments of inertia on the diagonal. If all q s would be zero, only the kinetic energies of translation and rigid rotation would survive.

The potential-like term U is the Watson term:

proportional to the trace of the effective reciprocal inertia tensor.

The fourth term in the Watson Hamiltonian is the kinetic energy associated with the vibrations of the atoms (nuclei) expressed in normal coordinates qs, which as stated above, are given in terms of nuclear displacements ρ by

Finally V is the unexpanded potential energy by definition depending on internal coordinates only. In the harmonic approximation it takes the form

See also


  1. W. Kołos and L. Wolniewicz, Nonadiabatic Theory for Diatomic Molecules and Its Application to the Hydrogen Molecule, Rev. Mod. Phys. vol. 35, pp. 473-483 (1963)
  2. R. G. Woolley and B. T. Sutcliffe, P.-O. Löwdin and the Quantum Mechanics of Molecules in Fundamental World of Quantum Chemistry, E. J. Brändas and E. S. Kryachko (Eds.), Vol. 1, 21-65, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2003.
  3. C. Eckart, Some studies concerning rotating axes and polyatomic molecules, Physical Review, vol. 47, pp. 552-558 (1935).
  4. B. Podolsky, Quantum-mechanically correct form of Hamiltonian function for conservative system, Phys. Rev., vol. 32, p. 812 (1928)
  5. E. Bright Wilson, Jr. and J. B. Howard The Vibration-Rotation Energy Levels of Polyatomic Molecules I. Mathematical Theory of Semirigid Asymmetrical Top Molecules, J. Chem. Phys. vol. 4, pp. 260-268 (1936)
  6. B. T. Darling and D. M. Dennison, The water vapor molecule, Phys. Rev., vol. 57, pp. 128-139 (1940).
  7. J. K. G. Watson, Simplification of the molecular vibration-rotation Hamiltonian, Mol. Phys. vol. 15, 479-490 (1968)
  8. L. C. Biedenharn and J. D. Louck, Angular Momentum in Quantum Physics, volume 8 of Encyclopedia of Mathematics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, 1981.