House of Lords: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Nick Gardner
mNo edit summary
 
(35 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
{|align="left" cellpadding="5" style="background:lightgray; width:95%; border: 1px solid #aaa; margin:10px; font-size: 92%;"
{|align="left" cellpadding="5" style="background:lightgray; width:95%; border: 1px solid #aaa; margin:10px; font-size: 92%;"
| This article  was last updated in February 2012.  
| This article  was last updated on 10 October 2022.  
|}
|}
{{Image|House of Lords 2011.jpg|right|400px|House of Lords chamber, Palace of Westminster, London, in 2011.}}
<br><br><br>
<br><br><br>


The '''House of Lords''' is the second chamber of the [[Parliament of the United Kingdom]]<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/lords ''House of Lords'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref>. Its  principal functions are to initiate, scrutinise and amend legislation. It has no general power of veto, but it attaches importance to its ability to return proposed legislation to the [[House of Commons (United Kingdom)|House of Commons]], the lower chamber of Parliament, for further consideration.<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/documents/lords-information-office/holwork.pdf ''The Work of the House of Lords'', House of Lords, 2009].</ref>
The '''House of Lords''' is the other chamber, besides the [[House of Commons (United Kingdom)|House of Commons]], of the [[Parliament of the United Kingdom]].<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/lords ''House of Lords'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> The House of Lords initiates, scrutinises and amends legislation. It has no general power of veto, but it has limited powers to return proposed legislation to the [[House of Commons (United Kingdom)|House of Commons]], for further consideration. It is composed mainly of appointed "Life Peers".
 
==History==
The [[History of the House of Lords]]  encompasses the history of its nominal predecessors, the [[Anglo-Saxon Witan]] and the [[Norman Great Council]], who were advisors to English monarchs. The current concept stems from the change that took place in 1341, when representatives of the towns and counties began to meet in their own chamber, started to deliberate separately from the King and his leading clergy and nobles, and became known as the House of Commons. Its subsequent history is dominated by  a succession of transfers of its powers to the House of Commons, culminating in the Parliament Act of 1911 which effectively ended its ability to  control the passage of legislation. It nevertheless retains a significant deliberative rôle in the [[Parliament of the United Kingdom]]. In the Middle Ages the majority of the House were Lords Spiritual, but this ended with Henry VIII's dissolution of the monasteries, after which the majority were hereditary peers until 1999, when most were removed, leading to its present composition.
 
[[Scotland]] and Ireland were originally separate nations, even after they were ruled by the English monarch, and they had their own peerages.  When a 1707 Act of Union merged England and Scotland, the merged nation was called [[Great Britain]].  All peers who had sat in the [[English House of Lords]] held the same rank and offices in the new [[House of Lords of Great Britain]].  Scottish peers chose individuals from among their number who would also sit in the new House of Lords.  Similarly, the 1800 Act of Union that merged Great Britain and Ireland, closed the [[Irish House of Commons]] and the [[Irish House of Lords]].  All peers who had sat in the House of Lords of Great Britain held the same rank and offices in the new [[UK House of Lords]], supplemented by a subset of the Irish peers who had sat in the Irish House of Lords.


==Members and staff==
==Members and staff==
Line 11: Line 17:
* about 670 "life peers", who had been appointed by current and previous administrations, including eminent professionals and members of previous governments;
* about 670 "life peers", who had been appointed by current and previous administrations, including eminent professionals and members of previous governments;
* 26 "lords spiritual", who are current [[bishop]]s and archbishops of the [[Church of England]]: and,
* 26 "lords spiritual", who are current [[bishop]]s and archbishops of the [[Church of England]]: and,
* 92 "hereditary peers", who had been elected from the membership of the previous House of Lords<ref>who had been granted or inherited hereditary peerages granted by monarchs down the ages</ref>. (The exclusion of hereditary peers is among the legislative proposals for the reform of the House of Lords<ref>[http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/bills/lbill/2010-2012/0105/lbill_2010-20120105_en_1.htm ''House of Lords Reform Bill (HL Bill 105)'']</ref> that are currently under consideration.)
* 92 "hereditary peers", who had mostly<ref>The Duke of Norfolk, as Earl Marshal, and the Marquess of Cholmondeley, as acting Lord Great Chamberlain, sit ex officio.</ref> been elected from the membership of the previous House of Lords.<ref>who had been granted or inherited hereditary peerages granted by monarchs down the ages.</ref>  


The Leader of the House of Lords<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/about/mps-and-lords/principal/leader-lords/ ''Leader of the House of Lords'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> is a member of the Cabinet, who is responsible for the organisation of government business in the House of Lords. The Lord Speaker  presides over proceedings in the House of Lords chamber and chairs the House Committee, which supervises the House of Lords administration<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/lord-speaker/the-role-of-lord-speaker/ ''Role of the Lord Speaker '', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref>. The Clerk of the Parliaments is the head of the House of Lords administration and is supported by an office providing corporate planning and related services. Committee Office Clerks  organise inquiries, draft reports and sometimes travel  with their committees.
The Leader of the House of Lords<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/about/mps-and-lords/principal/leader-lords/ ''Leader of the House of Lords'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref>  organises  government business in the House of Lords, and the Lord Speaker<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/about/mps-and-lords/principal/lord-speaker/ ''The Lord Speaker'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> is effectively its president. Besides presiding over debates, the Lord Speaker  chairs the House Committee, which supervises the House of Lords administration.<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/lord-speaker/the-role-of-lord-speaker/ ''Role of the Lord Speaker '', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> The Clerk of the Parliaments is the head of the House of Lords administration and is supported by an office providing corporate planning and related services. Committee Office Clerks  organise inquiries, draft reports and sometimes travel  with their committees.


==The conduct of business==
==The conduct of business==
Government and opposition members sit on rows of benches facing each other as in the House of Commons, but the benches on each side are less closely spaced, and between them there are benches for the use of "Cross-bench Peers" who are Peers without party membership. The procedures used by the House of Lords are similar to those governing the [[House of Commons (United Kingdom)#The conduct of business|conduct of business in the House of Commons]], but the conduct of debates in the House of Lords is noticeably different.
Government and opposition Peers sit on rows of benches facing each other  
Business is conducted on a much more consensual basis, with no formal government control over the timetable. As in the House of Commons, government and opposition whips agree in advance the  amount of time to allocate to each item; but in the House of Lords the agreement is interpreted flexibly and may be altered in the course of a debate. Detailed scrutiny may be given to a Bill by Peers who have expertise or experience in the matters that it deals with. As a result of those differences, House of Lords debates tend to involve lively exchanges rather than  unrelated  successions of prepared statements
in the magnificent [http://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/building/palace/architecture/palace-s-interiors/lords-chamber/ House of Lords Chamber], on  benches that  are less closely spaced than those in the Commons chamber. Between them at one end is the Throne, and facing it at the other end are benches for the use of "cross-benchers", who are Peers with no party affiliation. Debates are chaired by the Lord Speaker, seated on the "woolsack"<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/site-information/glossary/woolsack/ ''The Woolsack'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> in front of the Throne. The procedures used in  debates are similar to those governing the [[House of Commons (United Kingdom)#The conduct of business|conduct of business in the House of Commons]], but the conduct of debates in the House of Lords is noticeably different.
<ref>[http://interim.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/making-legislation-guide/overview_of_lords_stages.aspx ''Overview of Lords Stages and differences from Commons Stages'', Cabinet Office, May 2010]</ref>.
Business is conducted on a much more consensual basis, with no formal government control over the timetable. As in the House of Commons, the time allocated to each item is agreed in advance by government and opposition whips, but in the House of Lords the agreement is interpreted flexibly and may be altered in the course of a debate. Bills are given detailed scrutiny, often  by Peers who have expertise or experience in the matters that they deal with.<ref>[http://interim.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/making-legislation-guide/overview_of_lords_stages.aspx ''Overview of Lords Stages and differences from Commons Stages'', Cabinet Office, May 2010]</ref> Debates tend to involve lively exchanges, rather than the unrelated  successions of prepared statements that tend to characterise Commons debates.
The select committees of the House of Lords are fewer and generally more wide-ranging than those of the House of Commons. Some of their reports provide Parliament with an accessible digest of the implications of significant domestic and European legisiative enactments and proposals.  
Of the five [[/Addendum#House of Lords Committees|House of Lords Committees]], two provide Parliament with reports on the implications of domestic and European legislative  proposals.  
The Lords Constitution Committee examines all Public Bills for constitutional implications and investigates broad constitutional issues. It assesses the impact of a Public Bill and  may publish a report<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/lords-select/constitution-committee/ ''Lords Constitution Committee'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref>.
The Lords Constitution Committee<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/lords-select/constitution-committee/ ''Lords Constitution Committee'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref>
The European Union Committee and its 7 sub-committees consider European Union legislative proposals before they are enacted.
investigates the constitutional implications of Public Bills (as well as  conducting  enquiries into constitutional issues), and the European Union Committee<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/hleu ''The EU Select Committee'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> with its seven sub-committees, reports on legislative proposals that are under consideration by the  European Union.


==Powers==
==Powers==
 
All House of Commons Bills must be sent for consideration by the House of Lords before they can be given Royal Assent and become Acts of Parliament. However, the powers of the House of Lords to deal with them are limited by a combination of law and convention. Under the Parliament Acts,<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/about/how/laws/parliamentacts/ ''The Parliament Acts'', www.parliament.gov.uk]</ref> money Bills become law one  month after being sent to the House of Lords, and cannot be amended there, and most other Commons Bills can only be held up  for about a year: the House of Commons can reintroduce them in the following session and pass them without the consent of the House of Lords. A bill to extend the life of Parliament is explicitly exempt from this, and the Lords have a full veto power over it. Under the Salisbury Convention<ref>[http://www.parliament.uk/documents/lords-library/hllsalisburydoctrine.pdf  ''The Salisbury Doctrine'', House of Lords Library, June 2006]</ref> the House of Lords does not oppose a Bill that fulfils a promise made in the majority party's election manifesto.
==Proposals for reform==
 
==History==
Strictly speaking, the House of Lords originated in the fourteenth century when the Commons took to meeting separately. For most practical purposes, however, it is identical to the Great Council, the Norman continuation of the Anglo-Saxon Witan or Witenagemot.
 
In the Middle Ages the Lords Spiritual were the majority. This changed in the reign of Henry VIII, when the dissolution of the monasteries removed abbots, priors and masters of orders, leaving the bishops outnumbered by the Lords Temporal. An act of 1641 removed them from the House, but it was repealed two decades later. When new bishoprics were created in the nineteenth century to cope with shifting populations, an act was passed limiting the number of Church of England bishops in the House to 26: the Archbishops of Canterbury and York, the Bishops of London, Durham and Winchester, and the 21 other diocesan bishops in office for longest, excluding the Bishop of Sodor and Man, whose diocese is outside the United Kingdom proper.
 
Chapter 14 of Magna Carta speaks of "earls and greater barons" receiving individual summons to the Council. Originally the question of who counted as a "greater" baron was political, but by the seventeenth century the House had evolved the doctrine that, if someone received a summons to Parliament and he or his heir attended, this created a "barony by writ of summons" descendible to heirs. In the Wensleydale case (1876) the House confirmed that, while the Queen, as fountain of honour, could create whatever titles she wished, with whatever rules of succession she wished, they could only confer seats in the House if they satisfied certain conditions; in particular, in that case, a life peerage could not. Parliament then passed an act authorizing a limited number of "Lords of Appeal in Ordinary", commonly known as "Law Lords", with life peerages, to carry out the House's business as a court of appeal. In 1958 another act allowed unlimited life peerages, and the first women entered the House under its provisions. Female inheritors of peerages were not allowed to sit in the House until 1963.
 
Under the Acts of union between England and Scotland in 1707, the Scottish peers elected for each Parliament 16 of their number. When Ireland joined the union in 1801, its peers were granted the right to elect 28 of their number, but in this case the elections were for life. After most of Ireland became independent in the 1920s, this procedure ceased to operate, and the representative peers of Ireland gradually died out, the last of them, the Earl of Kilmorey, dying in 1961. The Church of Ireland was represented by 4 bishops from 1801 to 1870, after which it was disestablished under the Gladstone government. In 1963, all Scottish peers were granted the right to sit in the House. Another reform in that act was to grant inheritors of peerages the right to disclaim them, thus allowing them to sit in the House of Commons instead (if elected).
 
Up to the early twentieth century, the Lords and Commons had comparable power, and Prime Ministers were about equally likely to sit in either House (Disraeli even moved to the Lords in the middle of his term of office, in 1876). Occasionally, the Sovereign might enforce the will of the Commons against the Lords by creating new peers, or threatening to do so. A convention evolved that the Lords would not interfere in financial matters. However, in 1909 the Lords violated this convention by rejecting the increase in death duties in Lloyd George's budget. Edward VII agreed to dissolve Parliament to allow the government to seek a fresh mandate. In the ensuing election in January 1910, the Liberals lost their large majority and came in neck and neck with the Unionists. However, the Irish Nationalists and Labour supported them and the Lords backed down. The new king, George V, then agreed to repeat the process, and a second election in December produced almost identical results. After the King agreed to create new peers if necessary, the Lords agreed to the Parliament Act 1911. This provided that, if the Commons passed a bill in three successive sessions over about two years, it could be sent for Royal Assent as an act if the Lords still refused to pass it. An exception was made for bills to extend the life of Parliament, which still required the Lords' agreement. Contrariwise, bills certified by the Speaker as "money bills" could be sent for Royal Assent if the Lords did not pass them within a month.
 
The 1911 act was only ever used three times (though the threat had its effects). In 1914 acts were passed under it to disestablish the Anglican church in Wales, and to set up what would now be called a devolved Parliament for Ireland. (The implementation of the latter was deferred on the outbreak of war, and events moved on, so that it never took effect at all.) And in 1949 it was used to pass the Parliament Act 1949, which amended it to say that a bill only had to be passed in two successive sessions over a period of about two years. This act was itself only used once before the 1997 election (for the War Crimes Act introduced by Mrs Thatcher's government). However, with the election of a government committed to reforming the House, the latter seems to have decided it had nothing to lose by exercising its powers to the full, and the act was used a number of times under the Labour government.
 
The main reform made by the Labour government was the removal of most hereditary peers. It si important to note here that this included peers of first creation, not just those who had inherited their titles. A compromise negotiated with the Conservative leader in the Lords (behind his leader's back, for which he was sacked) allowed 92 to remain for the time being, a tenth of the total existing at the time. Of the 92, 2 were ex officio (see above) and the remainder elected.
 
In addition, the Labour government removed the judicial authority of the House (apart from its own internal affairs), transferring them to a new Supreme Court, though its initial judges were simply the existing Law Lords.
 
Another change they made was to the chairing of the House. Originally the King presided, and in theory the Queen could do so today. In practice, the last monarch to preside over ordinary business in the House was Queen Anne, and the last time a monarch even attended to grant Royal Assent in person was in 1856. Nowadays the Queen attends only for the formal opening ceremony. In the absence of the monarch the House is chaired by its Speaker, an office until recently normally combined with that of Lord Chancellor and a Crown appointment. The Labour government separated the two posts and allowed the House to elect its own Speaker.
 
By the general election of 2010, all three main parties were committed in principle to a wholly or mainly elected House of Lords (or Senate). In 2011 the coalition government published a draft reform bill, subject to amendment after consultation. They plan to put the legislation through in time for the 2015 election. The proposal is to move to a house of 240 elected members, 60 appointed members and 12 bishops. These (apart from the bishops) would fill their posts for a 15-year term, without possibility of renewal. This would be introduced progressively over three Parliaments. Thus, in 2015, 80 new members would be elected and 20 appointed, while the existing House would select two-thirds of its members to continue to 2020. Similarly, in 2020, another 100 new members would be added and another third of the existing House removed, and the process would be completed in 2025. Thus the House would eventually consist mostly of elected members, but these would be elected for staggered long terms, so that the House of Commons would always have a more recent electoral mandate.


==References==
==References==
{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]

Latest revision as of 11:01, 29 August 2024

This article is a stub and thus not approved.
 Main Article
 Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Timelines [?]
Addendum [?]
 
https://en.citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=House_of_Lords&printable=yes
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.
This article was last updated on 10 October 2022.
House of Lords chamber, Palace of Westminster, London, in 2011.




The House of Lords is the other chamber, besides the House of Commons, of the Parliament of the United Kingdom.[1] The House of Lords initiates, scrutinises and amends legislation. It has no general power of veto, but it has limited powers to return proposed legislation to the House of Commons, for further consideration. It is composed mainly of appointed "Life Peers".

History

The History of the House of Lords encompasses the history of its nominal predecessors, the Anglo-Saxon Witan and the Norman Great Council, who were advisors to English monarchs. The current concept stems from the change that took place in 1341, when representatives of the towns and counties began to meet in their own chamber, started to deliberate separately from the King and his leading clergy and nobles, and became known as the House of Commons. Its subsequent history is dominated by a succession of transfers of its powers to the House of Commons, culminating in the Parliament Act of 1911 which effectively ended its ability to control the passage of legislation. It nevertheless retains a significant deliberative rôle in the Parliament of the United Kingdom. In the Middle Ages the majority of the House were Lords Spiritual, but this ended with Henry VIII's dissolution of the monasteries, after which the majority were hereditary peers until 1999, when most were removed, leading to its present composition.

Scotland and Ireland were originally separate nations, even after they were ruled by the English monarch, and they had their own peerages. When a 1707 Act of Union merged England and Scotland, the merged nation was called Great Britain. All peers who had sat in the English House of Lords held the same rank and offices in the new House of Lords of Great Britain. Scottish peers chose individuals from among their number who would also sit in the new House of Lords. Similarly, the 1800 Act of Union that merged Great Britain and Ireland, closed the Irish House of Commons and the Irish House of Lords. All peers who had sat in the House of Lords of Great Britain held the same rank and offices in the new UK House of Lords, supplemented by a subset of the Irish peers who had sat in the Irish House of Lords.

Members and staff

The current membership of the House of Lords[2][3] consists of

  • about 670 "life peers", who had been appointed by current and previous administrations, including eminent professionals and members of previous governments;
  • 26 "lords spiritual", who are current bishops and archbishops of the Church of England: and,
  • 92 "hereditary peers", who had mostly[4] been elected from the membership of the previous House of Lords.[5]

The Leader of the House of Lords[6] organises government business in the House of Lords, and the Lord Speaker[7] is effectively its president. Besides presiding over debates, the Lord Speaker chairs the House Committee, which supervises the House of Lords administration.[8] The Clerk of the Parliaments is the head of the House of Lords administration and is supported by an office providing corporate planning and related services. Committee Office Clerks organise inquiries, draft reports and sometimes travel with their committees.

The conduct of business

Government and opposition Peers sit on rows of benches facing each other in the magnificent House of Lords Chamber, on benches that are less closely spaced than those in the Commons chamber. Between them at one end is the Throne, and facing it at the other end are benches for the use of "cross-benchers", who are Peers with no party affiliation. Debates are chaired by the Lord Speaker, seated on the "woolsack"[9] in front of the Throne. The procedures used in debates are similar to those governing the conduct of business in the House of Commons, but the conduct of debates in the House of Lords is noticeably different. Business is conducted on a much more consensual basis, with no formal government control over the timetable. As in the House of Commons, the time allocated to each item is agreed in advance by government and opposition whips, but in the House of Lords the agreement is interpreted flexibly and may be altered in the course of a debate. Bills are given detailed scrutiny, often by Peers who have expertise or experience in the matters that they deal with.[10] Debates tend to involve lively exchanges, rather than the unrelated successions of prepared statements that tend to characterise Commons debates. Of the five House of Lords Committees, two provide Parliament with reports on the implications of domestic and European legislative proposals. The Lords Constitution Committee[11] investigates the constitutional implications of Public Bills (as well as conducting enquiries into constitutional issues), and the European Union Committee[12] with its seven sub-committees, reports on legislative proposals that are under consideration by the European Union.

Powers

All House of Commons Bills must be sent for consideration by the House of Lords before they can be given Royal Assent and become Acts of Parliament. However, the powers of the House of Lords to deal with them are limited by a combination of law and convention. Under the Parliament Acts,[13] money Bills become law one month after being sent to the House of Lords, and cannot be amended there, and most other Commons Bills can only be held up for about a year: the House of Commons can reintroduce them in the following session and pass them without the consent of the House of Lords. A bill to extend the life of Parliament is explicitly exempt from this, and the Lords have a full veto power over it. Under the Salisbury Convention[14] the House of Lords does not oppose a Bill that fulfils a promise made in the majority party's election manifesto.

References

  1. ↑ House of Lords, www.parliament.gov.uk
  2. ↑ UK Parliament: 'Lords by party and type of peerage '. Last updated January 2012.
  3. ↑ Membership, House of Lords briefing, 2009.
  4. ↑ The Duke of Norfolk, as Earl Marshal, and the Marquess of Cholmondeley, as acting Lord Great Chamberlain, sit ex officio.
  5. ↑ who had been granted or inherited hereditary peerages granted by monarchs down the ages.
  6. ↑ Leader of the House of Lords, www.parliament.gov.uk
  7. ↑ The Lord Speaker, www.parliament.gov.uk
  8. ↑ Role of the Lord Speaker , www.parliament.gov.uk
  9. ↑ The Woolsack, www.parliament.gov.uk
  10. ↑ Overview of Lords Stages and differences from Commons Stages, Cabinet Office, May 2010
  11. ↑ Lords Constitution Committee, www.parliament.gov.uk
  12. ↑ The EU Select Committee, www.parliament.gov.uk
  13. ↑ The Parliament Acts, www.parliament.gov.uk
  14. ↑ The Salisbury Doctrine, House of Lords Library, June 2006
Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=House_of_Lords&oldid=975191"