Jose Padilla
Template:TOC-right Jose Padilla is an American who was arrested, in 2002 by Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) agents, on charges that he was plotting to detonate a "dirty bomb". Soon afterwards, however, he was declared an enemy combatant by President George W. Bush,[1] and transferred to military custody and interrogation. In Rumsfeld v. Padilla, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that the President did not have authority, in this case, to put him into military detention. He was eventually transferred back to the judicial system. In 2007, he was convicted of lesser charges, "conspiracy to murder, maim or kidnap," in the context of providing support to Islamic militants in Chechnya, Somalia, and other areas outside the United States.
U.S. District Court judge Marcia G. Cooke, observed "There is no evidence that these defendants personally maimed, kidnapped or killed anyone in the United States or elsewhere." In sentencing him to 27 years rather than the life sentence sought by the prosecution, she considered his time in "I do find that the conditions were so harsh for Mr. Padilla . . . they warrant consideration in the sentencing in this case." [2]
Civilian arrest
Originally, he was arrested as a material witness warrant from the New York the federal prosecutor's office in Manhattan, where Comey was then the U.S. attorney.
Declaration of nonjudicial status
Part of the government case was that he was an "enemy combatant", having been in Afghanistan in late 2001.
He was held in the U.S. Navy prison in Charleston, Virginia, and interrogated, using coercive methods, by military personnel. Jack Goldsmith, Assistant Attorney General for the Office of Legal Counsel in the Bush Administration, wrote that there was a problem of public perception of the Padilla case: as opposed to the situation in ex parte Quirin, where the accused were clearly Nazi saboteurs, "Padilla had no uniform to discover and his connection to al Qaeda and his dangerousness were questioned" Military action in the United States against someone in street clothes violates the deepest taboos of our constitutinal system..."[3]
Appeals
Padilla v. Rumsfeld led to his transfer back to civilian control in 2005.[4]
Civilian trial
He was convicted on this charge and the coercive interrogations were kept outside court review.[5]
References
- ↑ George W. Bush (June 9, 2002), Memorandum to the Secretary of Defense
- ↑ Peter Whoriskey and Dan Eggen (January 23, 2008), "Judge Sentences Padilla to 17 Years, Cites His Detention", Washington Post
- ↑ George W. Bush (2007), The Terror Presidency, Norton, pp. 117-118
- ↑ George W. Bush (November 20, 2005), Memorandum for the Secretary of Defense, Re: Transfer of Detainee Jose Padilla
- ↑ Jenny S. Martinez (August 17, 2007), "The Real Verdict on Jose Padilla", Washington Post