Glenn Beck: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
(New page: '''Glenn Beck''' (1964-) is a U.S. political opinion broadcaster and author, with a show on Fox News, and his own website, books and national tours. ...)
 
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Glenn Beck''' (1964-) is a U.S. [[political opinion broadcasting|political opinion broadcaster]] and author, with a show on [[Fox News]], and his own website, books and national tours. He is strongly identified with [[American conservatism]], and has started a movement called the [[9-12 Project]], strongly critical of liberal ideas and suspicious of large government.
'''Glenn Beck''' (1964-) is a U.S. [[political opinion broadcasting|political opinion broadcaster]] and author, with a show on [[Fox News]], and his own website, books and national tours. He is strongly identified with [[American conservatism]], and has started a movement called the [[9-12 Project]], strongly critical of liberal ideas and suspicious of large government.
Among Fox opinion commentators, Beck differentiates himself as a highly emotional "revivalist in a troubled land", with an apocalyptic vision, as opposed to [[Bill O'Reilly]] as an "outsider" and [[Sean Hannity]] as an ideologue. Conservative writer [[David Frum]] called  Beck's success the “...product of the collapse of conservatism as an organized political force, and the rise of conservatism as an alienated cultural sensibility. It’s a show for people who feel they belong to an embattled minority that is disenfranchised and cut off." He calls himself an entertainer that challenges his critics: "I’m a rodeo clown...It takes great skill.”<ref name=NYT2009-03-30>{{citation
| date = 30 March 2009
| author = Brian Stelter and Bill Carter
| title = Fox News’s Mad, Apocalyptic, Tearful Rising Star
| journal = [[New York Times]]
| url = http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/30/business/media/30beck.html?pagewanted=print}}</ref>
[[Tom Rosenstiel]], of the [[Project for Excellence in Journalism]], speaks of his appeal in historical terms: “There was a lot of radio evangelism during the Depression. People were frustrated and frightened. There are a lot of scary parallels now.”
==9-12 Project==
{{main|9-12 Project}}
He created the [[9-12 Project]] as a movement whose name invokes U.S. response to the [[9-11 Attacks]], <blockquote>On 9/10 we were burying our heads in the sand or we were playing politics. It was about Republicans or Democrats. On 9/11 we were freaking out and no one knew who attacked us, where did this come from, what is this. On 9/12 no one in the government had to tell us what to do. We just did it.<ref name=Announce>{{citation
| title = Glenn Beck: The 9/12 Project
| author = Glenn Beck
| journal = The Glenn Beck Program
| date = 17 March 2009
| url = http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/22802/
}}</ref></blockquote>
According to his open letter of November 2009, Beck said, <ref name=Letter>{{citation
| title  = 11/23: Glenn Beck Reveals The Plan in Open Letter
| author = Glenn Beck
| url =http://www.the912project.com/category/the-plan/
| date = 23 November 2009
| publisher = 9-12 Project}}</ref> "Today, I have stopped looking for a leader to show us the way out because I have come to realize that the only one who can truly save our country… is us."  Speaking on Fox, he also said "Coming this January, my whole approach changes on this program “This next year is going to be critical, and I think it's going to change and I think we are going to set it right, at least set our course right. And if that means the Democrats or the Republicans are destroyed along the way, well, good. Good.” " <ref name=Politico2009-11-21>{{citation
| title =  Beck's plan: Rally followers, sell books
| author = Kenneth P. Vogel
| date = 21 November 2009 | journal = Politico
| url = http://dyn.politico.com/printstory.cfm?uuid=18BB9B93-18FE-70B2-A88A18A5253A4258}}</ref>
The project has no explicit funding, but its website content is produced by Beck's production company, [[Mercury Radio Arts]], and hosted on [[Fox News]]' servers. There is considerable synergy between this and the [[Tea Party Movement]]. <ref name=AP2009-09-12>{{citation
| journal = Associated Press
| title = Tea Party Washington D.C. PHOTOS: Conservative Protesters Rally Against Big Government
| date = 12 September 2009
| url = http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/09/12/taxpayer-march-on-washing_n_284477.html}}</ref> The project website, indeed, quotes analysis of an upcoming Republican senatorial primary as a confrontation between the Republican establishment and the tea party.<ref name=TheHill>{{citation
| title = Republican's exit could clear the way for Tea Party vs. GOP incumbent Bennett
| author = Aaron Blake | date = 11 November 2009 | journal = The Hill
| url = http://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/67429-challengers-exit-could-clear-way-for-tea-party-vs-bennett}}</ref>
Some of Beck's announcements also tie with tours publicizing his book, ''Arguing with Idiots''.<ref name=Politico2009-11-20>{{citation
| title = Beck to announce 'big plan' for 2010
| author = Kenneth P. Vogel
| date = 20 November 2009 | journal = Politico
| url =http://dyn.politico.com/printstory.cfm?uuid=137C9ABE-18FE-70B2-A88E1BC3F0B684D4}}</ref> Critics have said that Beck's change in direction, from general encouragement of his listeners to organize to active participation in action, tie to publicity for his book. Beck's direct participation in political activities may put the project under the jurisdiction of campaign finance law. <ref name=Politico2009-11-21 />  Further complicating the political finance situation are campaigns for office by people associated with the project., such as [[Dan Eichenbaum]] in [[North Carolina]]'s 11th Congressional District<ref name=PRNW2009-12-09>, {{citation
| url  = http://www.pr.com/press-release/198123
| title = Founding Member of 9-12 Project Stands for Election to Congress
| date = 9 December 2009
| journal = PR.com}}</ref> running against incumbent Democrat [[Heath Shuler]].<ref name=DrDan>{{citation
| url = http://drdan4congress.com/about/
| title = About
| publisher = Dr. Dan for Congress}}</ref>
==Advertiser boycott==
His calling called [[Barack Obama]] a racist over the [[Henry Louis Gates, Jr.]] arrest <ref name=Politico2009-07-28>{{citation
| date = 28 July 2009
| title = Fox's Beck: Obama is 'a racist'
| author = [[Michael Calderone]]
| journal = Politico
| url= http://www.politico.com/blogs/michaelcalderone/0709/Foxs_Beck_Obama_is_a_racist.html}}</ref> has triggered a boycott by some advertisers.  According to [[MediaMatters]], 80 advertisers reportedly dropped their ads since he called President Obama a "racist" who has a "deep-seated hatred of white people." <ref name=MM2009-12-15> {{citation
| title = So who's still advertising on on Beck?
| journal = [[MediaMatters]]
| date = 15 December 2009
| url = http://mediamatters.org/blog/200912150048}}</ref> Writing in [[The Atlantic]], [[Conor Clarke]] does not see this as a free speech issue: "It seems to me that the right to free speech does not give you the right to massive corporate underwriting. Glenn Beck can defend "the white culture" and call Obama a "racist" in poverty and in private." Clarke said he can accept, however, the Fox statement that "'While the advertising boycott has generated substantial media coverage', Fox News said it has not impacted the network's revenues or Beck's audience. 'The advertisers referenced have all moved their spots from Beck to other programs on the network so there has been no revenue lost,'"<ref name=Atlantic2009-08-25>{{citation
| date = 25 August 2009 | author = Conor Clarke
| title = Why Hasn't the Glenn Beck Boycott Hurt Fox News? | journal = [[The Atlantic]]
| url = http://politics.theatlantic.com/2009/08/why_hasnt_the_glenn_beck_boycott_hurt_fox_news.php}}</ref>
==References==
{{reflist|2}}

Revision as of 23:10, 15 December 2009

Glenn Beck (1964-) is a U.S. political opinion broadcaster and author, with a show on Fox News, and his own website, books and national tours. He is strongly identified with American conservatism, and has started a movement called the 9-12 Project, strongly critical of liberal ideas and suspicious of large government.

Among Fox opinion commentators, Beck differentiates himself as a highly emotional "revivalist in a troubled land", with an apocalyptic vision, as opposed to Bill O'Reilly as an "outsider" and Sean Hannity as an ideologue. Conservative writer David Frum called Beck's success the “...product of the collapse of conservatism as an organized political force, and the rise of conservatism as an alienated cultural sensibility. It’s a show for people who feel they belong to an embattled minority that is disenfranchised and cut off." He calls himself an entertainer that challenges his critics: "I’m a rodeo clown...It takes great skill.”[1]

Tom Rosenstiel, of the Project for Excellence in Journalism, speaks of his appeal in historical terms: “There was a lot of radio evangelism during the Depression. People were frustrated and frightened. There are a lot of scary parallels now.”

9-12 Project

For more information, see: 9-12 Project.

He created the 9-12 Project as a movement whose name invokes U.S. response to the 9-11 Attacks,

On 9/10 we were burying our heads in the sand or we were playing politics. It was about Republicans or Democrats. On 9/11 we were freaking out and no one knew who attacked us, where did this come from, what is this. On 9/12 no one in the government had to tell us what to do. We just did it.[2]

According to his open letter of November 2009, Beck said, [3] "Today, I have stopped looking for a leader to show us the way out because I have come to realize that the only one who can truly save our country… is us." Speaking on Fox, he also said "Coming this January, my whole approach changes on this program “This next year is going to be critical, and I think it's going to change and I think we are going to set it right, at least set our course right. And if that means the Democrats or the Republicans are destroyed along the way, well, good. Good.” " [4]

The project has no explicit funding, but its website content is produced by Beck's production company, Mercury Radio Arts, and hosted on Fox News' servers. There is considerable synergy between this and the Tea Party Movement. [5] The project website, indeed, quotes analysis of an upcoming Republican senatorial primary as a confrontation between the Republican establishment and the tea party.[6]

Some of Beck's announcements also tie with tours publicizing his book, Arguing with Idiots.[7] Critics have said that Beck's change in direction, from general encouragement of his listeners to organize to active participation in action, tie to publicity for his book. Beck's direct participation in political activities may put the project under the jurisdiction of campaign finance law. [4] Further complicating the political finance situation are campaigns for office by people associated with the project., such as Dan Eichenbaum in North Carolina's 11th Congressional District[8] running against incumbent Democrat Heath Shuler.[9]

Advertiser boycott

His calling called Barack Obama a racist over the Henry Louis Gates, Jr. arrest [10] has triggered a boycott by some advertisers. According to MediaMatters, 80 advertisers reportedly dropped their ads since he called President Obama a "racist" who has a "deep-seated hatred of white people." [11] Writing in The Atlantic, Conor Clarke does not see this as a free speech issue: "It seems to me that the right to free speech does not give you the right to massive corporate underwriting. Glenn Beck can defend "the white culture" and call Obama a "racist" in poverty and in private." Clarke said he can accept, however, the Fox statement that "'While the advertising boycott has generated substantial media coverage', Fox News said it has not impacted the network's revenues or Beck's audience. 'The advertisers referenced have all moved their spots from Beck to other programs on the network so there has been no revenue lost,'"[12]


References

  1. Brian Stelter and Bill Carter (30 March 2009), "Fox News’s Mad, Apocalyptic, Tearful Rising Star", New York Times
  2. Glenn Beck (17 March 2009), "Glenn Beck: The 9/12 Project", The Glenn Beck Program
  3. Glenn Beck (23 November 2009), 11/23: Glenn Beck Reveals The Plan in Open Letter, 9-12 Project
  4. 4.0 4.1 Kenneth P. Vogel (21 November 2009), "Beck's plan: Rally followers, sell books", Politico
  5. "Tea Party Washington D.C. PHOTOS: Conservative Protesters Rally Against Big Government", Associated Press, 12 September 2009
  6. Aaron Blake (11 November 2009), "Republican's exit could clear the way for Tea Party vs. GOP incumbent Bennett", The Hill
  7. Kenneth P. Vogel (20 November 2009), "Beck to announce 'big plan' for 2010", Politico
  8. , "Founding Member of 9-12 Project Stands for Election to Congress", PR.com, 9 December 2009
  9. About, Dr. Dan for Congress
  10. Michael Calderone (28 July 2009), "Fox's Beck: Obama is 'a racist'", Politico
  11. "So who's still advertising on on Beck?", MediaMatters, 15 December 2009
  12. Conor Clarke (25 August 2009), "Why Hasn't the Glenn Beck Boycott Hurt Fox News?", The Atlantic