Culture area: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Joe Quick
(created stub)
 
imported>Joe Quick
m (→‎Shortcomings: minor rewording)
Line 5: Line 5:


==Shortcomings==
==Shortcomings==
Culture areas are limited in their usefulness because their borders are rarely well defined.  It is quite likely that two neighboring [[ethnic group]]s that conceptually live in different culture areas will have more in common than two groups from opposite extremes of the same culture area.  An example is the borderland between [[Mesoamerica]] and the [[Greater Southwest]], where ancient trade routes facilitated cultural exchange - one might walk from Arizona to Guatemala and never notice an abrupt shift in traditional cultural patterns.
Culture areas are limited in their usefulness because their borders are rarely well defined.  It is quite likely that two neighboring [[ethnic group]]s that supposedly live in different culture areas will have more in common than two groups from opposite extremes of the same culture area.  An example is the borderland between [[Mesoamerica]] and the [[Greater Southwest]], where ancient trade routes facilitated cultural exchange - one might walk from Arizona to Guatemala and never notice an abrupt shift in traditional cultural patterns.


==Notes==
==Notes==

Revision as of 18:02, 28 March 2007

A culture area is a region in which the environment and the cultures that are present are very similar. the concept of culture areas was first developed around the turn of the nineteenth century,[1] and has grown to become a useful tool to help anthropologists conduct ethnological studies.

Applications

Culture areas are commonly evoked in cross-cultural anthropology to facilitate the generalization of cultural phenomena and broad comparison of cultures that have developed in similar environments.

Shortcomings

Culture areas are limited in their usefulness because their borders are rarely well defined. It is quite likely that two neighboring ethnic groups that supposedly live in different culture areas will have more in common than two groups from opposite extremes of the same culture area. An example is the borderland between Mesoamerica and the Greater Southwest, where ancient trade routes facilitated cultural exchange - one might walk from Arizona to Guatemala and never notice an abrupt shift in traditional cultural patterns.

Notes

  1. Mark Q. Sutton and E.N. Anderson. (2004) Introduction to Cultural Ecology. ISBN 0-7591-0531-6.