Bowling (cricket): Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>John Leach
m (John Leach moved page Underarm bowling incident of 1981 to Underarm bowling (cricket): merge into coverage of the whole subject area)
imported>John Leach
(rewritten to provide coverage of the historic subject and put the 1981 incident into perspective)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
The '''underarm bowling incident of 1981''', also known as the '''Australian underarm bowling incident''', was an international [[sport]]ing controversy in 1981, between [[Australia]] and [[New Zealand]], which resulted in [[underarm bowling]] being made illegal by the [[International Cricket Council]]. It is considered one of the most disgraceful moments in the history of [[Cricket (sport)|cricket]], and seriously damaged the image of Australians as fair sportsmen.
In [[cricket (sport)|cricket]], '''underarm bowling''' is as old as the sport itself. Until the introduction of the [[roundarm bowling (cricket)|roundarm]] style in the first half of the 19th century, bowling was always performed with an underarm action wherein the bowler's hand is below his waist at the point of delivery. For centuries, bowling was performed exactly as in [[bowls]] because, depending on the pace of delivery, the ball was rolled (slow), skimmed (fast) or trundled (medium) along the ground with no bounce. Despite the variations in pace, the basic action was essentially the same and there are surviving illustrations from the first half of the eighteenth century which depict the bowler with one knee bent forward and his bowling hand close to the ground, while the ball is bowled towards a batsman armed with a bat shaped something like a large hockey stick and guarding a two-stump wicket.


==The events==
In the early 1760s, cricket was revolutionised by the introduction of [[pitched delivery bowling]]. The bouncing ball was an evolutionary change and has been described as the event that took cricket out of its "pioneering phase" into what may be termed its "pre-modern phase" (i.e., which ended when [[overarm bowling (cricket)|overarm bowling]] ushered in the modern game in 1864) and effectively created a different code of cricket, just as there are now two different codes of [[rugby football]]. By 1772, when the completion of detailed scorecards became commonplace, the pitched delivery was established practice and, in response to it, the modern straight bat had been invented, the hockey stick shape of bat being of little or no use against a bouncing ball.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.jl.sl.btinternet.co.uk/stampsite/cricket/ladstolords/1751.html |title=From Lads to Lord's: 1751 – 1760 |date=10 October 2012 |publisher= |deadurl=yes |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20121010153249/http://www.jl.sl.btinternet.co.uk/stampsite/cricket/ladstolords/1751.html |archivedate=10 October 2012 |df=dmy-all}}</ref>
{{Image|Underarmscreenshot.jpg|right|200px|A screenshot of the underarm delivery with Trevor Chappell bowling, Brian McKechnie facing, and Bruce Edgar at the non-strikers end.}}
The controversial match occurred on 1 February 1981, when Australia was playing a [[One Day International]] final against New Zealand in the 1980-1981 [[Benson and Hedges]] [[World Series Cup]], at the Melbourne Cricket Ground.<ref>{{Cite web | title = 3rd Final: Australia v New Zealand at Melbourne, Feb 1, 1981 | publisher = Cricinfo | date = 1 February 1981 | url = http://www.cricinfo.com/ci/engine/match/65317.html | accessdate = 14 July 2013}}</ref> The five-game series was tied one-all as New Zealand had won the first match and the Australia the second match. It was the third match in which this incident took place. Australia having won the toss chose to bat and accumulated a reasonable score of 235 for 4, in 50 overs. Australian captain Greg Chappell top scored with an innings of 90, despite appearing to have been caught on the boundary by Martin Snedden on 52 and refusing to walk.<ref>{{cite book |last = Blofeld |first = Henry |chapter = World Series Cup - Third Final Match: Australia v New Zealand 1980-81 |title = Wisden Cricketers' Almanack 1982 |publisher = John Wisden & Co |year = 1982 |url = http://www.cricinfo.com/wisdenalmanack/content/story/155265.html |isbn = 978-1-4081-2466-6}}</ref> New Zealand strongly replied by scoring 229 in 49.5 overs with Bruce Edgar scoring 102 not out, and they required six runs to tie the match with two wickets remaining, off the final delivery. Trevor Chappell prepared to bowl the final ball of the match, and had already claimed two wickets that over, one dubious lbw (Richard Hadlee) and one bowled (Ian Smith) with his regular bowling action, when Brian McKechnie walked out to bat with one delivery to face. Then Greg Chappell instructed his bowler (his younger brother) Trevor Chappell to roll the ball underhand along the pitch so that McKechnie who was on strike, a lower-order number ten batsman who had never before hit a six in his career, could not score six runs from over the boundary of the world's largest cricket ground. McKechnie was unable to loft the ball for six and was forced to block out the delivery, then threw his bat in the direction towards the New Zealand [[dressing room]] in disgust as both teams left the field of play. Even though Australia had just won the match, spectators booed and jeered the Australian team off the field for displaying such bad sportsmanship.<ref>{{Cite web|last=Williamson|first=Martin|title=Underhand, underarm|url=http://www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/498574.html|publisher=ESPN Cricinfo|date=29 January 2011|accessdate=4 October 2013}}</ref> As it turned out, in the confusion before the final ball was bowled, one of the fielders, Dennis Lillee, had failed to walk into position, meaning that the underarm ball at delivery was a [[no-ball]], because under the playing conditions Australia had one too many fielders outside the field restriction circle, but was not called so by the square-leg umpire. Extra police came on to the field to cordon the ground from a crowd invasion, and a furious New Zealand captain Geoffrey Howarth ran up to the umpires, disgusted at what transpired, pointing out that under the ''Rules of the Benson & Hedges Cup - 1980'' Appendix H (iii) No Ball - Mode of Delivery; no bowler may deliver the ball underarm. The umpires refused to overturn their decision to end play, pointing out that that specific rule had not been included for the current series.


The act was roundly criticized on both sides of the [[Tasman Sea]], with both nations' [[Prime Minister]]s castigating the Australian team. Then Prime Minister of New Zealand, [[Robert Muldoon]], called it 'the most disgusting incident I can recall in the history of cricket', and 'it was an act of cowardice and I consider it appropriate that the Australian team were wearing yellow'.<ref>{{Cite news | last = Rowney | first = Jo-Anne | title = The line between gamesmanship and cheating  | newspaper = BBC News Magazine | location = London | language = English | publisher = British Broadcasting Corporation | date = 13 July 2009 | url = http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/8148183.stm | accessdate = 14 July 2013}}</ref> His Australian counterpart [[Malcolm Fraser]] agreed that it was 'contrary to the traditions of the game'.<ref>{{Cite web | title = The Underarm incident | publisher = Melbourne Cricket Ground | date = 1 February 2009 | url = http://www.mcg.org.au/History/Cricket/Memorable%20Moments/The%20Underarm%20incident.aspx | accessdate = 14 July 2013}}</ref> Veteran cricket commentator Richie Benaud called it 'a disgraceful performance' and 'one of the worst things I have ever seen done on a cricket field'.<ref>{{Cite web | last = Benaud | first = Richie | title =  Most disgraceful moment in the history of cricket | publisher = YouTube | date = 1 February 1981 | url = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K65_spUU05s | format = .flv | accessdate = 14 July 2013}}</ref> Despite this, the Australian Cricket Board took no action against the Chappell brothers. The incident angered many in the cricketing community prompting an immediate change in the laws of cricket.<ref>{{Cite journal | last = Frith | first = David | title = Grim prophecy fulfilled | journal = Wisden Cricket Monthly | publisher = John Wisden & Co | location = London | date = March 1981 | url = http://www.cricinfo.com/wcm/content/story/235391.html | issn = 0263-9041 | accessdate = 14 July 2013}}</ref> It was the cause of much anger and consternation of New Zealanders towards Australia, and still casts a shadow over trans-Tasman sporting events. As a result of this match, underarm bowling was banned in all limited over cricket games by the International Cricket Council as 'not within the spirit of the game'. Since the incident, both Greg Chappell and Trevor Chappell have refused to discuss the matter or offer an apology, and the result has never been reviewed, cancelled or altered.
Underarm was largely superseded by roundarm from the late 1820s onward and then almost totally after overarm was legalised in 1864. Underarm prevailed in the days of rudimentary pitch preparation because the ball did not run smoothly over the uneven surface and batsmen could easily be deceived by deflections off the rough. As better pitches with level surfaces became common, greater bounce became a necessity for the bowlers and so the game evolved through the bowling styles. By the 1920s, underarm was virtually extinct in the first-class game though there have been isolated instances of its usage, generally by non-bowlers called on to try something different or for a bit of fun when a match was in a stalemate situation.
 
Underarm was dramatically reintroduced on 1 February 1981 when, in the final of the Benson & Hedges World Series Cup at the [[Melbourne Cricket Ground]], the Australian bowler Trevor Chappell, under orders from his captain and brother [[Greg Chappell]], rolled the final ball all along the ground to prevent New Zealand batsman Brian McKechnie from hitting it for the six runs that New Zealand needed to tie the match. The incident had widespread repercussions, being condemned as gamesmanship and sharp practice. It was not actually a [[no ball (cricket)|no ball]] because an underarm action was legal at the time.
 
As a direct result of the incident, the [[International Cricket Council]] ruled that underarm bowling in [[limited overs cricket]] is "not within the spirit of the game". This necessitated a change in the ''[[Laws of Cricket]]'' and Law 21.1.2 now states that "underarm bowling shall not be permitted except by special agreement before the match".<ref>[https://www.lords.org/mcc/laws-of-cricket/laws/law-21-no-ball/ Law 21 – No Ball]. MCC (2018).</ref>


==Notes==
==Notes==
{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}

Revision as of 02:54, 29 October 2018

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Video [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

In cricket, underarm bowling is as old as the sport itself. Until the introduction of the roundarm style in the first half of the 19th century, bowling was always performed with an underarm action wherein the bowler's hand is below his waist at the point of delivery. For centuries, bowling was performed exactly as in bowls because, depending on the pace of delivery, the ball was rolled (slow), skimmed (fast) or trundled (medium) along the ground with no bounce. Despite the variations in pace, the basic action was essentially the same and there are surviving illustrations from the first half of the eighteenth century which depict the bowler with one knee bent forward and his bowling hand close to the ground, while the ball is bowled towards a batsman armed with a bat shaped something like a large hockey stick and guarding a two-stump wicket.

In the early 1760s, cricket was revolutionised by the introduction of pitched delivery bowling. The bouncing ball was an evolutionary change and has been described as the event that took cricket out of its "pioneering phase" into what may be termed its "pre-modern phase" (i.e., which ended when overarm bowling ushered in the modern game in 1864) and effectively created a different code of cricket, just as there are now two different codes of rugby football. By 1772, when the completion of detailed scorecards became commonplace, the pitched delivery was established practice and, in response to it, the modern straight bat had been invented, the hockey stick shape of bat being of little or no use against a bouncing ball.[1]

Underarm was largely superseded by roundarm from the late 1820s onward and then almost totally after overarm was legalised in 1864. Underarm prevailed in the days of rudimentary pitch preparation because the ball did not run smoothly over the uneven surface and batsmen could easily be deceived by deflections off the rough. As better pitches with level surfaces became common, greater bounce became a necessity for the bowlers and so the game evolved through the bowling styles. By the 1920s, underarm was virtually extinct in the first-class game though there have been isolated instances of its usage, generally by non-bowlers called on to try something different or for a bit of fun when a match was in a stalemate situation.

Underarm was dramatically reintroduced on 1 February 1981 when, in the final of the Benson & Hedges World Series Cup at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, the Australian bowler Trevor Chappell, under orders from his captain and brother Greg Chappell, rolled the final ball all along the ground to prevent New Zealand batsman Brian McKechnie from hitting it for the six runs that New Zealand needed to tie the match. The incident had widespread repercussions, being condemned as gamesmanship and sharp practice. It was not actually a no ball because an underarm action was legal at the time.

As a direct result of the incident, the International Cricket Council ruled that underarm bowling in limited overs cricket is "not within the spirit of the game". This necessitated a change in the Laws of Cricket and Law 21.1.2 now states that "underarm bowling shall not be permitted except by special agreement before the match".[2]

Notes

  1. From Lads to Lord's: 1751 – 1760 (10 October 2012). Archived from the original on 10 October 2012.
  2. Law 21 – No Ball. MCC (2018).