Archive:Should we permit or disallow commercial use of CZ-originated articles?: Revision history

31 August 2020

• curprev 07:4907:49, 31 August 2020‎ imported>John Stephenson‎ 38,671 bytes +38,671‎ Category:Archived Pages
• curprev 07:4307:43, 31 August 2020‎ imported>John Stephenson‎ m 38,661 bytes +1‎ John Stephenson moved page CZ:Should we permit or disallow commercial use of CZ-originated articles? to Archive:Should we permit or disallow commercial use of CZ-originated articles?: archiving old discussion

24 January 2008

• curprev 15:0015:00, 24 January 2008‎ imported>Yuval Langer‎ m 38,661 bytes +1‎ Moving Template:communication to the bottom of the page

15 September 2007

• curprev 13:3313:33, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,660 bytes +162‎ →‎Argument: Commercial use permits maximum distribution of content.
• curprev 13:2913:29, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,498 bytes +79‎ →‎Argument: Commercial use permits maximum distribution of content.
• curprev 13:2113:21, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,478 bytes −764‎ →‎Reply: Commercial use isn't necessary for competition.: Tightening up argument, and deleting problematic reply
• curprev 13:1713:17, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 39,242 bytes 0‎ Moving to bottom. This must be the worst argument for the affirmative
• curprev 12:1912:19, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 39,242 bytes +599‎ Argument: Commercial use facilitates competition. RENAMED: Argument: Commercial use would make it easier to fork the ''Citizendium.'' Uh, yeah. That's an ''affirmative'' argument?
• curprev 12:0212:02, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,643 bytes +90‎ →‎Reply: Many educational projects have sufficient contributors, and they don't even use a free license.
• curprev 11:5611:56, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,553 bytes −673‎ Deleted overspecialized, and very unpersuasive, arguments
• curprev 11:3711:37, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 39,226 bytes +552‎ →‎Argument: "Noncommercial" is not well defined.
• curprev 11:2911:29, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,674 bytes +37‎ No edit summary
• curprev 11:2911:29, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 35,401 bytes −3,236‎ →‎Argument: "Noncommercial" is not well defined.: Moving to the end--probably the weakest of all the arguments
• curprev 11:2811:28, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,670 bytes +33‎ →‎Argument: "Noncommercial" is not well defined.
• curprev 11:2311:23, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,637 bytes +3,236‎ Oops, what is wrong with my head today :-)
• curprev 11:2211:22, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 35,401 bytes −3,236‎ →‎Argument: "Noncommercial" is not well defined.: This is a NEGATIVE argument. Sheesh
• curprev 11:1911:19, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,637 bytes +218‎ →‎Negative: Disallow commercial use.
• curprev 11:1711:17, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,419 bytes 0‎ No edit summary
• curprev 11:1611:16, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,419 bytes +38,419‎ →‎Reply: Many educational projects have sufficient contributors, and they don't even use a free license.
• curprev 11:1611:16, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,479 bytes −38‎ →‎Argument: Commercial use is part of the definition of free/open content.
• curprev 10:3910:39, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 37,637 bytes −880‎ →‎Reply to "so what": Deleted section that is merely suggestive, and does not actually make its point. See talk.
• curprev 10:3710:37, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,185 bytes −332‎ →‎Reply to "so what": This paragraph is redundant and nonresponsive
• curprev 10:3610:36, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,403 bytes −114‎ OK, maybe the TOC is better than nothing
• curprev 10:3510:35, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,396 bytes −121‎ No edit summary
• curprev 10:3110:31, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,517 bytes +448‎ Simply not an argument, this
• curprev 10:2110:21, 15 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,069 bytes +21,911‎ Removing useless table of contents (it's just too long)

10 September 2007

• curprev 10:1510:15, 10 September 2007‎ imported>Larry Sanger‎ 38,069 bytes +21,911‎ No edit summary

7 August 2007

• curprev 03:0203:02, 7 August 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 38,050 bytes +416‎ "For encyclopedia projects, if there are ever any competitors for ours, well, if they are any good, we'll just use their best articles...to strengthen our project." - Jimmy Wales, Jul 25, 2001

22 July 2007

• curprev 07:2507:25, 22 July 2007‎ imported>Howard Arvi Hughes‎ m 37,634 bytes −1‎ →‎Reply: Argument is falsified by experience

21 July 2007

• curprev 22:3622:36, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 37,635 bytes +582‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise: Italicize
• curprev 19:4919:49, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 37,627 bytes +508‎ →‎Rebuttal
• curprev 19:4819:48, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 37,623 bytes +504‎ →‎Rebuttal: add quote
• curprev 19:1719:17, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 37,119 bytes +46‎ →‎Rebuttal
• curprev 17:1917:19, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 37,073 bytes +20‎ →‎Rebuttal
• curprev 17:1817:18, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 37,062 bytes +9‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise
• curprev 16:4516:45, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 37,053 bytes +1,387‎ →‎Reply: The ''Citizendium'' website ''is'' maximum distribution.: add minor point
• curprev 16:2916:29, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Aleksander Stos‎ 36,936 bytes +1,270‎ →‎Argument: Having incompatible licenses is a nuisance.: this appears to be new. Is it ok to put arguments directly here instead of passing through the forum?
• curprev 15:4515:45, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Aleksander Stos‎ 36,094 bytes +428‎ →‎Rebuttal to CZ as max distribution: as far as I remember...
• curprev 14:4414:44, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 35,795 bytes +45‎ →‎Rebuttal
• curprev 14:2514:25, 21 July 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 35,750 bytes +84‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise: formatting

3 June 2007

• curprev 22:5822:58, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 35,666 bytes −2‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise
• curprev 22:5822:58, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 35,668 bytes +21‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise
• curprev 22:3322:33, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Robert Tito‎ m 35,647 bytes +1,016‎ →‎Negative: Disallow commercial use.
• curprev 22:1722:17, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 35,585 bytes +2‎ →‎Negative: Disallow commercial use.
• curprev 22:1722:17, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 35,583 bytes +414‎ →‎Negative: Disallow commercial use.: *''gotspe'' - insolent brutality, roughly
• curprev 21:3121:31, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Robert Tito‎ m 35,539 bytes +370‎ →‎Negative: Disallow commercial use.
• curprev 21:1221:12, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 35,169 bytes +538‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise
• curprev 21:1021:10, 3 June 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ 35,140 bytes +570‎ →‎With the GFDL for CZ original articles, we might as well resolve ourselves to be a feeder-wiki, leading to our own demise

15 May 2007

• curprev 05:4705:47, 15 May 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 34,564 bytes −6‎ →‎Rebuttal
• curprev 05:4605:46, 15 May 2007‎ imported>Stephen Ewen‎ m 34,570 bytes −61‎ →‎Rebuttal