Archive:Should we confirm stated credentials or check bios cursorily?: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Larry Sanger
No edit summary
 
imported>Larry Sanger
Line 2: Line 2:


== The issue explained neutrally ==
== The issue explained neutrally ==
''See [[CZ Talk:Application Review Procedure‎]] for background to this debate.''


= Affirmative: check, and require evidence of, any credentials stated in a bio =
= Affirmative: check, and require evidence of, any credentials stated in a bio =


= Negative: check only basic ''bona fides''; rely on "soft security" for accuracy of details=
= Negative: check only basic ''bona fides''; rely on "soft security" for accuracy of details=

Revision as of 21:28, 27 March 2007

Policy argument summary started March 27, 2007

The issue explained neutrally

See CZ Talk:Application Review Procedure‎ for background to this debate.

Affirmative: check, and require evidence of, any credentials stated in a bio

Negative: check only basic bona fides; rely on "soft security" for accuracy of details