File talk:Venn Diagrams.PNG

Rims

I agree that it is good to make it clear what the role of the rims is in these visualizations, but I don't think rectangular cuts are the way to go. --Daniel Mietchen 02:39, 10 July 2011 (UTC)

If you are talking about the rectangular "universal" set then I agree: It is irrelevant and should therefore be omitted.

If the boundaries are used to identify the "red" and the "blue" set then the complete coloured circles have to be present in all diagrams.

For my taste the boundaries are much too thick -- they should be only thick enough to clearly show their colours.

In the formulas, the symbols for the binary operations are too big. Compare

$A\cap B,A\cup B,A\setminus B$

Instead of one picture with 3 diagrams, three separate pictures would be more useful. Perhaps with circles of different sizes (and the forumla above or below the diagrams. In addition,

a diagram for $A\subset B$ and (perhaps) also for the relative complement $\complement _{B}A$

in the same graphical design would be useful.

--Peter Schmitt 14:56, 10 July 2011 (UTC)

See also the image Venn diagrams XY.PNG, in Venn diagram, which has the same format. There are undoubtedly many ways to approach the picture, and I'd guess the way to decide what to do is to compare different actual pictures. There are a few things to notice:

• The pictures in the articles are reduced in size, and the tiny details of the regions where the rims intersect are not really an issue.
• The pictures are accurate.
• Making the rims thinner has the effect of requiring a different method to distinguish between the sets, because the coloring of the rims becomes impossible to see at a reasonable figure size. If the sets are shaded differently or cross-hatched, or whatever, it seems to work well for the intersection because large regions of the two sets are not part of the intersection, but it doesn't work so well for the union because the entire two sets are taken by the union leaving no identifying markings for the individual sets.
• The universal set is mentioned in the articles, so it isn't exactly irrelevant. The source here suggests such an approach. See also Figure 1-7 here, Illustration 16 here, diagram 4 here, Figures 2.22 & 2.23 here, the discussion surrounding Figure 5.1 here and on and on. It appears that the choice of a rectangle for the universal set in Venn diagrams is very usual. John R. Brews 22:18, 10 July 2011 (UTC)