CZ:Core Articles: Difference between revisions
imported>Larry Sanger |
imported>Larry Sanger |
||
| Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
=== Topic choice === | === Topic choice === | ||
Each workgroup nominates 99 topics (33 per column). Exceptions are Biology, Health Sciences, History, Geography, Business, Games, Hobbies, and Sports, which may nominate 198 topics (66 per column). For some already-existing article lists, for ideas, please see [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/CZ:High_priority_articles_for_pilot] and [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/User:Anthony_Argyriou/WPbasicarticles1]. | Each workgroup nominates 99 topics (33 per column). Exceptions are Biology, Health Sciences, History, Geography, Business, Games, Hobbies, and Sports, which may nominate 198 topics (66 per column). For some already-existing article lists, for ideas, please see [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/CZ:High_priority_articles_for_pilot] and [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/User:Anthony_Argyriou/WPbasicarticles1]. List articles in ''only'' one workgroup. All topics must be either completely unwritten, a micro-stub, or status=4. | ||
=== Points, attaching and claiming === | |||
Each workgroup may award 10 points for the five most important articles in the group, 5 points for the ten next most important, and 2 points for the 14 next most important (down to #33, the bottom of the first column). The rest (in the middle and right columns) are worth a point apiece. | |||
The first and/or most motivated editor attaches points to articles. If after a reasonable period it appears no editor is going to step up, then the most qualified and motivated author issues the points. | |||
''None'' of these articles may come from Wikipedia, if you want it to count. In fact, if you want, you can entirely replace a status = 4 Wikipedia-sourced article with a new CZ article. | |||
For now, we do not track first draft authors on the talk page or the metadata page of an article, but only on [[CZ:Core Articles]]. | |||
Authors may claim points on [[CZ:Core Articles/Scores]] only after their article length (and non-Wikipediahood) has been OK'd. | |||
Original proposal and forum board: http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php/topic,1221.0.html | Original proposal and forum board: http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php/topic,1221.0.html | ||
__TOC__ | __TOC__ | ||
==Natural Sciences== | ==Natural Sciences== | ||
=== Astronomy === | === Astronomy === | ||
Revision as of 08:44, 25 September 2007
| Citizendium Initiatives | ||
|---|---|---|
| Eduzendium | Featured Article | Recruitment | Subpages | Core Articles | Uncategorized pages | Requested Articles | Feedback Requests | Wanted Articles |
|width=10% align=center style="background:#F5F5F5"| |}
What are core articles?
Core articles are our top priority articles--articles that are most in demand and most important for us to include in an encyclopedia that has any hope of being comprehensive.
How does the core articles initiative work?
Essentially, we list our unwritten core articles here on this page, negotiating about which articles really are our highest priority. We then invite people to write articles on those topics, awarding points for any draft that is 250 words or longer. We tally points on CZ:Core Articles/Scores.
Page format
This is one big long page, divided into sections, one for each workgroup. Each section should be written in three columns. However, make sure the columns break after each workgroup. (So each workgroup header is in one column which spans all three.) Total number of articles on page will be about 4,000. So it will be a big page, but that's OK, it's not too big.
Each line of a workgroup's section begins with # so that the entries are numbered. Most important (highest point value) entries should be listed first. Format of a line evolves like this:
The original entry simply says "French painting" is worth 5 points:
# [[French painting]] (5)
Once Jane Doe has written a draft article over 250 words, she may take credit:
# [[French painting]] (5) - [[User:Jane Doe|]]
Someone confirms that Jane has written 250 words, writing "OK":
# [[French painting]] (5) - [[User:Larry Sanger|]] - OK
Finished.
Note: anyone may edit any section of this page so that the section is in conformity with these formatting guidelines! Be Bold!
Topic choice
Each workgroup nominates 99 topics (33 per column). Exceptions are Biology, Health Sciences, History, Geography, Business, Games, Hobbies, and Sports, which may nominate 198 topics (66 per column). For some already-existing article lists, for ideas, please see [1] and [2]. List articles in only one workgroup. All topics must be either completely unwritten, a micro-stub, or status=4.
Points, attaching and claiming
Each workgroup may award 10 points for the five most important articles in the group, 5 points for the ten next most important, and 2 points for the 14 next most important (down to #33, the bottom of the first column). The rest (in the middle and right columns) are worth a point apiece.
The first and/or most motivated editor attaches points to articles. If after a reasonable period it appears no editor is going to step up, then the most qualified and motivated author issues the points.
None of these articles may come from Wikipedia, if you want it to count. In fact, if you want, you can entirely replace a status = 4 Wikipedia-sourced article with a new CZ article.
For now, we do not track first draft authors on the talk page or the metadata page of an article, but only on CZ:Core Articles.
Authors may claim points on CZ:Core Articles/Scores only after their article length (and non-Wikipediahood) has been OK'd.
Original proposal and forum board: http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php/topic,1221.0.html
Natural Sciences
Astronomy
|
|
|
Biology
|
I'll have to learn the wiki coding, but here find some potential "Core" articles starting with letter "A"--Anthony.Sebastian (Talk) 20:28, 20 September 2007 (CDT)
Acid-base physiology
Adaptability
Adipose tissue biology
Adenovirus
Adrenal physiology
Aging
Agriculture
Amino acid metabolism and function
Animism
Ants
Antigen
Apocrine gland physiology
Arterial system
Oswald T. Avery (DNA as the genetic material)
Well, bear in mind that on the proposal in question, there are only 200 articles in each of Biology and Health Sciences--and they have to be the 200 "core," most important, articles. I suspect there would be a lot more than 200 biology articles if you were to continue the list at that level of specialization. --Larry Sanger 20:34, 20 September 2007 (CDT)
Agree re "core" concept. Thinking to make a draft list of potential core topics biology, then cull to a 200 core by consensus of Workgroup. --Anthony.Sebastian (Talk) 19:22, 21 September 2007 (CDT)
Some 'potential' core topics starting with letter "B" and not already listed as Biology articles:
Baboons
Bears
Bioterrorism
Bone
Buffon, Comte de
Butter
Butterflies
--Anthony.Sebastian (Talk) 19:51, 21 September 2007 (CDT)
Chemistry
Earth Sciences
- Atmosphere
- Cainozoic
- Dinosaur
- Earth (10) - Nereo Preto
- Earthquake
- El Niño-Southern Oscillation
- Fossil
- Glacier
- Geology (5) - Nereo Preto
- Holocene
- Mesozoic
- Mountain
- North Atlantic oscillation
- Ocean
- Paleontology
- Paleozoic
- Plate tectonics (5) - Nereo Preto
- Precambrian
- Quaternary
- Rock (geology)
- Soil
- Thermohaline circulation (5) - Nereo Preto