User:ElectionJune2012: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>ElectionJune2012
(→‎Voting: changed date)
No edit summary
 
(57 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{AccountNotLive}}
<!-- Account used for December 2011 EC elections and referenda. -->
{|align=center border=1 style="width: 68%;"
==Results of the Election==
The Election Committee has now certified the results of the tallying:
Twenty-eight Citizens cast valid ballots.  One ballot was received after voting closed and was not counted.
'''Anthony Sebastian''' was elected Managing Editor with 19 yays, 7 abstentions, and 2 spoiled ballots.
'''Referendum #1''' was the only closely contested one.  It received 17 yays and 10 nays.  Because it proposed to modify the Charter, a two-thirds majority in favor was needed for the referendum to pass.  Of the 27 votes cast, it received only 62.9% votes in favor, however, meaning that the referendum failed.
'''Referendum #2''' passed by a majority of 23 yays to 3 nays.
'''Referendum #3''' passed by a majority of 26 yays to 1 nay.
'''Referendum #4''' passed by a majority of 25 yays to 2 nays.
Hayford Peirce, Chairman of the Election Committee
|-
==Managing Editor Nominees (in alphabetical order) and links to their statements==
==Managing Editor Nominees (in alphabetical order) and links to their statements==
{| border=1 style="width: 100%;"
{| border=1 style="width: 100%;"
|-
|-
!Name of nominee
!Name of nominee
!Acceptance of nomination
!Acceptance of nomination  
!Statement
!Statement
|-
|-
|style="background-color:lime"|[[User:<first candidate>|<first candidate]]
|style="background-color:lime"|[[User:Anthony Sebastian|Anthony Sebastian]]
|style="background-color:lime"|Accept - [[User:<first candidate>|<first candidate>]] <Time/Date of acceptance> (UTC)
|style="background-color:lime"|Accept  
|style="background-color:lime"|[[CZ:Election<date>/Nominations/Managing Editor/<first candidate>|Statement]].
|style="background-color:lime"|[[CZ:Elections June 2012/Nominations/Managing Editor/User:Anthony Sebastian|Statement]].
|-
 
|style="background-color:lime"|[[User:<second candidate>|<second candidate]]
|style="background-color:lime"|Accept - [[User:<second candidate>|<second candidate>]] <Time/Date of acceptance> (UTC)
|style="background-color:lime"|[[CZ:Election<date>/Nominations/Managing Editor/<second candidate>|Statement]].
|-
|style="background-color:lime"|[[User:<third candidate>|<third candidate]]
|style="background-color:lime"|Accept - [[User:<third candidate>|<third candidate>]] <Time/Date of acceptance> (UTC)
|style="background-color:lime"|[[CZ:Election<date>/Nominations/Managing Editor/<third candidate>|Statement]].
|}
|}
----
----
----


==Referenda==
==Referenda==
The election will include voting on the following referenda.
The election will vote on the following referenda.
----
----


===Citizen initiated referenda===
===Citizen initiated referenda===


====Referendum 1: <name>====
====Referendum 1: Charter majority amendment====
Proposed by [[User:<proposer name>]]
Proposed by [[User:John Stephenson|John Stephenson]]


<text of the referenda>
1. [[CZ:Charter#Article 37|Article 37, section 'Furthermore', point 3]] of the Citizendium Charter shall be modified to replace the text referring to a "qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast":


''The above referendum is further discussed at [[CZ:Election<date>/Referenda/<referendum number>]].  
*''Any amendment to and any change of this Charter shall require a referendum and shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of more than half the votes validly cast. ''
 
2. In the event that this referendum passes and one or more other referenda on the Charter held at the same time receive more than 50% of valid votes in support but not a two-thirds majority, then the new version of Article 37 shall apply to those other referenda, i.e. they shall also pass.
 
''The above referendum is further discussed at [[CZ:Election_June_2012/Referenda/1|Referendum 1]].  


<select one of the following and add after the last sentence.><br>
As this referendum modifies the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast.''<br>
As this referendum modifies the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast.''<br>
As this referendum does not modify the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.''
----
 
====Referendum 2: Import of material to Citizendium====
Proposed by [[User:Anton Sweeney|Anton Sweeney]]
 
The Citizendium community affirms:
* the principles stated at [[CZ:About]], namely that Citizendium ''"is an open wiki project dedicated to creating a free, comprehensive, and reliable repository of structured knowledge."'' and
* the open nature of the project, as indicated by our use of the [[Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0]] licence.
 
The community therefore:
* rescinds [http://ec.citizendium.org/wiki/EC:R-2010-013/_Importation_of_articles Editorial Council Resolution R-2010-013] of 12th December, 2010;
* affirms that material that complies with our inclusion criteria may be imported into Citizendium, provided it is imported from a source either in the public domain or otherwise compatible with Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 licence;
* encourages citizens who import such material to:
** convert it to Citizendium standards and style, and
** work to improve it without undue delay; and
* affirms that where such imported material has not been worked on within 30 days of import, it may be removed, moved to userspace, moved to Cold Storage, or otherwise archived, at the request of any citizen.
 
''The above referendum is further discussed at [[CZ:Election_June_2012/Referenda/2|Referendum 2]]
 
As this referendum does not modify the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.<br>
----
----


===Council initiated referenda===
===Council initiated referenda===


====Referendum 2: <name>====
====Referendum 3: Reducing the number of members of the Management Council====
Proposed by <the council that proposed it>
Proposed by the Management Council


<text of the referenda>
As allowed by Article 25, Section 4, item 1, the number of Management Council members will be reduced to 3 on July 1, 2012.


''The above referendum is further discussed at [[CZ:Election<date>/Referenda/<referendum number>]].
''The above referendum is further discussed at [http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php/topic,4343.msg45699.html#msg45699 Referendum 3].''


<select one of the following and add after the last sentence.><br>
As this referendum does not modify the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.
As this referendum modifies the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast.''<br>
----
As this referendum does not modify the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.'''
 
====Referendum 4: Reducing the number of members of the Editorial Council====
Proposed by the Editorial Council
 
The size of the Editorial Council shall be reduced from seven to five members (to take effect by July 1, 2012), comprising three Editor seats and two Author seats.
 
''The above referendum is further discussed at [http://ec.citizendium.org/wiki/EC:2012-015 Referendum 4]''
 
As this referendum does not modify the [[CZ:Charter|Charter]], it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.
----
----


Line 61: Line 105:
First, make sure you are logged in to ''Citizendium'', then:
First, make sure you are logged in to ''Citizendium'', then:
# Copy the text of the "Ballot paper" from the next section.
# Copy the text of the "Ballot paper" from the next section.
# On the menu on the far left of this page, under '''Toolbox''', you will see a menu item, '''[[Special:EmailUser/<election user name>|E-mail this user]]'''.  Click on that link.
# On the menu on the far left of this page, under '''Toolbox''', you will see a menu item, '''[[Special:EmailUser/ElectionJune2012|E-mail this user]]'''.  Click on that link.
# This will take you to a page where you can enter the text of your email.
# This will take you to a page where you can enter the text of your email.
# Paste in the text of the "Ballot paper" that you previously copied.
# Paste in the text of the "Ballot paper" that you previously copied.
# Under the heading '''MC member''', type the name of your preferred candidate(s).  (You may vote for up to '''<number of open MC seats>''' candidates.  You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Managing Editor''', type the name of your preferred candidate. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''EC Authors''', type the name of your preferred candidate(s).  (You may vote for up to '''<number of open EC author seats>''' candidates.  You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''EC Editors''', type the name of your preferred candidate(s).  (You may vote for up to '''<number of open EC editor seats>''' candidates.  You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Managing Editor''', type the name of your preferred candidate. (You may vote for only '''one''' candidate.  You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Ombudsman''', type the name of your preferred candidate.  (You may vote for only '''one''' candidate.  You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Referendum 1''', type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum.  (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Referendum 1''', type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum.  (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# <duplicate the previous line for all referenda, changing '''Referendum 1''' to the appropriate referendum number>
# Under the heading '''Referendum 2''', type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum.  (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Referendum 3''', type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum.  (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Under the heading '''Referendum 4''', type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum.  (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
# Check what you've entered to make sure it accurately reflects your preferences.
# Check what you've entered to make sure it accurately reflects your preferences.
# Click on the '''Send''' button.
# Click on the '''Send''' button.
Line 78: Line 120:
===Ballot paper===
===Ballot paper===


MC member


Managing Editor -- Anthony Sebastian is the only candidate


EC Authors


Referendum 1 — Charter Majority Amendment


EC Editors


Referendum 2 — Import of Material to Citizendium


Managing Editor


 
Referendum 3 — Reducing the Management Council
Ombudsman
 
 
Referendum 1
 
 
Referendum 2
 
.
.
.
 
Referendum <n>




Referendum 4 — Reducing the Editorial Council


[[Category:Elections]]
[[Category:Elections]]
[[Category:Council-initiated referenda]]
{{DEFAULTSORT:<year>, CZ Elections <month>}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:<year>, CZ Elections <month>}}
[[User:ElectionJune2012|ElectionJune2012]] 20:07, 6 June 2012 (UTC)
[[Category:CZ Authors|ElectionJune2012]][[Category:Economics Authors|ElectionJune2012]]
{{DEFAULTSORT:ElectionJune2012}}

Latest revision as of 02:49, 22 November 2023


The account of this former contributor was not re-activated after the server upgrade of March 2022.


Results of the Election

The Election Committee has now certified the results of the tallying:

Twenty-eight Citizens cast valid ballots. One ballot was received after voting closed and was not counted.

Anthony Sebastian was elected Managing Editor with 19 yays, 7 abstentions, and 2 spoiled ballots.

Referendum #1 was the only closely contested one. It received 17 yays and 10 nays. Because it proposed to modify the Charter, a two-thirds majority in favor was needed for the referendum to pass. Of the 27 votes cast, it received only 62.9% votes in favor, however, meaning that the referendum failed.

Referendum #2 passed by a majority of 23 yays to 3 nays.

Referendum #3 passed by a majority of 26 yays to 1 nay.

Referendum #4 passed by a majority of 25 yays to 2 nays.

Hayford Peirce, Chairman of the Election Committee


Managing Editor Nominees (in alphabetical order) and links to their statements

Name of nominee Acceptance of nomination Statement
Anthony Sebastian Accept Statement.

Referenda

The election will vote on the following referenda.


Citizen initiated referenda

Referendum 1: Charter majority amendment

Proposed by John Stephenson

1. Article 37, section 'Furthermore', point 3 of the Citizendium Charter shall be modified to replace the text referring to a "qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast":

  • Any amendment to and any change of this Charter shall require a referendum and shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of more than half the votes validly cast.

2. In the event that this referendum passes and one or more other referenda on the Charter held at the same time receive more than 50% of valid votes in support but not a two-thirds majority, then the new version of Article 37 shall apply to those other referenda, i.e. they shall also pass.

The above referendum is further discussed at Referendum 1.

As this referendum modifies the Charter, it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of two thirds of the votes validly cast.


Referendum 2: Import of material to Citizendium

Proposed by Anton Sweeney

The Citizendium community affirms:

  • the principles stated at CZ:About, namely that Citizendium "is an open wiki project dedicated to creating a free, comprehensive, and reliable repository of structured knowledge." and
  • the open nature of the project, as indicated by our use of the Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 licence.

The community therefore:

  • rescinds Editorial Council Resolution R-2010-013 of 12th December, 2010;
  • affirms that material that complies with our inclusion criteria may be imported into Citizendium, provided it is imported from a source either in the public domain or otherwise compatible with Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 licence;
  • encourages citizens who import such material to:
    • convert it to Citizendium standards and style, and
    • work to improve it without undue delay; and
  • affirms that where such imported material has not been worked on within 30 days of import, it may be removed, moved to userspace, moved to Cold Storage, or otherwise archived, at the request of any citizen.

The above referendum is further discussed at Referendum 2

As this referendum does not modify the Charter, it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.


Council initiated referenda

Referendum 3: Reducing the number of members of the Management Council

Proposed by the Management Council

As allowed by Article 25, Section 4, item 1, the number of Management Council members will be reduced to 3 on July 1, 2012.

The above referendum is further discussed at Referendum 3.

As this referendum does not modify the Charter, it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.


Referendum 4: Reducing the number of members of the Editorial Council

Proposed by the Editorial Council

The size of the Editorial Council shall be reduced from seven to five members (to take effect by July 1, 2012), comprising three Editor seats and two Author seats.

The above referendum is further discussed at Referendum 4

As this referendum does not modify the Charter, it shall be ratified if accepted by a qualified majority of the votes validly cast.


Voting

Voting in the Elections and Referendum runs from midnight UTC, June 10, 2012, to midnight UTC June 17, 2012.

Voting instructions

First, make sure you are logged in to Citizendium, then:

  1. Copy the text of the "Ballot paper" from the next section.
  2. On the menu on the far left of this page, under Toolbox, you will see a menu item, E-mail this user. Click on that link.
  3. This will take you to a page where you can enter the text of your email.
  4. Paste in the text of the "Ballot paper" that you previously copied.
  5. Under the heading Managing Editor, type the name of your preferred candidate. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
  6. Under the heading Referendum 1, type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
  7. Under the heading Referendum 2, type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
  8. Under the heading Referendum 3, type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
  9. Under the heading Referendum 4, type "Yes" if you wish to vote in favour of the referendum, or type "No" if you wish to vote against the referendum. (You may also abstain by not filling in anything in this section).
  10. Check what you've entered to make sure it accurately reflects your preferences.
  11. Click on the Send button.

That's it - you've just cast your ballot. Thank you for participating!

Ballot paper

Managing Editor -- Anthony Sebastian is the only candidate


Referendum 1 — Charter Majority Amendment


Referendum 2 — Import of Material to Citizendium


Referendum 3 — Reducing the Management Council


Referendum 4 — Reducing the Editorial Council